What do you think about the new judge? Poll Results - American Idol

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

American Idol What do you think about the new judge?

35 fans picked:

Eh, she&# 39; s OK

Eh, she's OK

40%

Love her!!

20%

Hate her!!

17%

I don&# 39; t know if I like that there&# 39; s a new judge....

I don't know if I like that there's a new judge. But I have nothing against her.

11%

(added by Avatar-Is-Life)

There&# 39; s a new judge..?

There's a new judge..?

I don&# 39; t know that much about her

I don't know that much about her

(added by nxtactress)

Huddyaddict12 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

11 comments

Hate her!!

Huddyaddict12 picked Hate her!! :

She just seems..well..to full of herself.

posted over a year ago.

Hate her!!

oneshyguy46 picked Hate her!! :

She is full of herself and really rude to the contestants (Simon does it in a more professional manner while she is very childish). Im scared that this change might destroy the show =/.

posted over a year ago.

Hate her!!

BeSafe picked Hate her!! :

Honestly I thought she was really mean to that chick who was like her biggest fan...and I mean come on you just got on this show why are you acting like that...from what I've seen so far I don't like her at all, and I agree she seems pretty full of herself, and I don't even really think she is very pretty...

posted over a year ago.

I don&# 39; t know if I like that...

Avatar-Is-Life picked I don't know if I like that there's a new judge. But I have nothing against her.:

she almost seems like a mixture of Paula ad Simon.
She's Annoying and Brutal!

posted over a year ago.

Love her!!

mrsblack_1089 picked Love her!! :

Well I wouldn't say that she was MEAN to that girl. She just told her that her voice wasn't going to make it. It could have been worse (i.e. Simon saying that Chelsea's voice sounded like 'A cat falling off the Empire State Building.'). I think she's pretty cool. She and Paula get along great, and it evens up everything better now, 2 guys, 2 girls. With that 'Bikini Girl' there would have been no controversy because Simon and Randy would have said yes and there would be no one to back up Paula's 'Why?!' I like her so far.

posted over a year ago.

Eh, she&# 39; s OK

BigSis35 picked Eh, she's OK:

She's pretty OK. It is nice having another girl judge. She is not as nice as Paula, but not as mean as Simon. Having a new judge is good, but Paula is my favorite.

posted over a year ago.