They hardly centered around Spottedleaf's relationship at all before she died. You could hardly tell they were in love.

Spottedleaf is dead. Sandstorm isn't. Plus Sandstorm is waaaay better!!

Forbidden relationships are getting a bit old, aren't they? Sandstorm and Firestar are just made for eachother though.

I don't really care that they're relationship is forbidden, they would make an excellent couple!

Sandstorm is way better. Besides, Firestar and Spottedleaf hardly knew eachother so I find it kinda silly how she already loves him.

I didn't even know they were in love until Firestar started having dreams about Spottedleaf!!!! All I can say is that he did a great job of hidding his love when she was alive!!!!

Sandstorm is a lucky gal!

sandstorm and firestar are so cute together! and if they weren't together squirrelflight and leafpool would have never existed.

Firestar was an apprentice and Spottedleaf was all grown up! It is odd that a grown up would love a ten year old. In human years that is how mature I would guess apprentices are.

sandstorm stinks!

Spottedleaf is too good for Firestar.

No no no Spottedleaf can't fall in love too much. Medicine cats can't have mates or kits.

i agree with 18wanda, BrambleLuvMe, kikklin, and WarriorsFan101

Firestar was to goody goody to have a forbidden relationship

Yeah, there really wasn't a relationship between Spottedleaf and Fireheart. I mean, it didn't really go anywhere. Even if it did, the plot of the first book moved too fast for the readers to bond with the relationship.

definitely sandstorm i liked him with spottedleaf but then she died so he should be with sandstorm