I WAS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOO­OOO­OO SAD!

I cried at both because it just an't fair for either1

I hate Bella and I cried for 50 pages after that!

i didnt like ethier they both mad me cry!!!

I like them both.
I adore Edward and Jacob is a great friend of mine (in my head).
Both hurt so much... but Edward leaving was so painful because we got to read what happened to Bella. She died and reading that was just so horrifying.

This part was pretty much tied with the end of Eclipse when Bella and Jacob talked and she kinda ok maybe kinda isnt the right word really hurt him...but i guess this part goes with him running away but...

it was his choice to run away... and it was a selfish choice... so i dont feel bad for him... but edward left her to save her... it was really sad

I dont think it was a selfish choice, the wedding invite tore him apart.
After he had worked so hard to make her see that she was in love with him.

i was crying sooooooo much when edward left, i had to stop and try to fight the tears so i could keep reading because i couldnt see because my eyes were too blurry from crying. i was so upset when he left, it was like he was a real person that i loved leaving me.

i cried my f-ing eyes out!

Edward leaving in New Moon....it was so sad.

they were both really sad. I fell in love with Edward in Twilight, then fell in love with Jacob in New Monn. In Eclipse, well, it was hard to see Edward and Jacob so broken. Bella is a little evil, but it's not her fault she fell in love with two guys.

that was horrible

You could totally feel the pain. Q__Q

I was devastated wen I read that. I waz like majorly upset I cried nd I NEVR cry

i was absolutely devastated. i cried for like ever! i bet i will cry every time i read it. i dont like jacob.

I Kinda Liked That Part And I Kinda Didnt...I Know I Could Care Less If Jacob Ran Away For Good...I Hate Him!!

i sat there n i had to stop reading n whipe my eyes b/c i couldnt c the page b/c it was blury b/c i was to busy ballin my eyes out!

edward was being a butthead wen he left in new moon. by the time he came back i was sick of bella and her feelings and i was glad to hav him back to make the story interesting

Both were heartbreaking, but I cried for hours over New Moon, so it wins. I suppose I just care more about Edward and Bella than about Jacob.

They both upset me soooooo much. I probably cried more when Edward left because there was more pages about that but if there was more pages about Jacob running away I would have my own personal river by now from reading all the books (and the death of Dimebag (R.I.P. 1966-2004) And I'm still crying because of that).

i cried my eyes out when edward left bella! ahh!!! *sniff, sniff,* lol i was just like "eh" when jacob left. i almost didnt read the epilouge...but i did anyway

It felt like bella was cheating on me! I knoe that this sounds wierd, but I have grown so into these books, I almost covered the page!

Jacob come back! lol I soo wanna give him a big hug! xxx

they were both too sad... I wanna hug!!!

It made me cry for days after that part I set the book down for a while. Then I finished it and know I have read Eclipse.

I hated wen bella kissed jacob. It just makes me sooo mad!! She is engaged to Edward and he has risked evreything for her and really does love her and she turns around and does this.Also what makes it worse is Edward doesnt react he is hurt emotianlly about it and i LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE EDWARD<33 Bella doesnt deserve him i will get edward<3 he can bite me =]

Seriously. I cried so hard when Jacob left. I just wanted to give him a big hug. I think I cried harder the second time I read it...

I cried it was so sad.

oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooops wel oh well

I'm not really sure what to pick, because I feel really bad for not being sad for Bella as much as maybe should of(I read that part really fast, I knew he was leaving anyway)
But I truely think the hardest thing to read was the fact that one of the characters fell in love with someone they can't really be with.

I WAS SOOOOO SAD!!!!! All I did while Edward was gone was read new moon and cry! Then when anybody even mentioned the name "Edward" even if it wasn't Edward Cullen, I would start tearing up. It was probably one of the saddest parts of my existence!!!!

i totsly had to try really hard not to cry!

This was *so* sad. I really just wanted to give him a hug. He deserves it :)

This was like so SAD! Honestly I cried! actually during a lot oftrhe book. The way SM wrote Bella's emotion was sooo effective.

I was reading new moon with my whole family in the room (like 12 people) all of a sudden you start hearing someone balling their eyes out. everyone was staring at me and i choked out "edward left bella".
for some reason when i opened my eyes everyone was gone.

I was so upset that i fliped to see when edward was coming back just so i knew how much crap i would have to read untill edward was back. i got about have way there and saw edwards name and was so excited cuz i wasn't very far. I kept reading until i got there and then got furious. I didn't realize bella would have hallucinations of him in her head. i was so mad i threw the book at the wall and didn't read it again till the next day.
i guess i just really really hate jacob black.
i hope billy accidentally runs him over with his wheel chair!!!

hahaaa sawabear basically sums up what i have to sayy!

and i didnt want bella to love jacob >:O
bc i knew it would break eddie's heartt :'(

both were annoying

i cried for sooooo long when edward left, and then he was going to kill himself because of jacob!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Edward is my favourite character so when he said he was leaving i was like "NOOOOOOOOO"

i was going crazy with rage and sadness both times

i hated that edward left, and no offense, but i hate Jacob

sad

i hate jacob. he was clearly trying to steal bella off edward

I LOVE EDWARD AND I LOVE JACOB !!!!!!!!!!!!

I cried soooo hard poor Bella

It was sad when Edward left Bella i cried.... =( its soo sad and when bella kissed Jacob when she was with Edward that was a low thing to do and also sad.......

LUV U JAKE AND ED..xxx

I felt so sorry for her when he left, but when she kissed Jacob i felt a hate i had never felt before!

whos that hottie in the jake pic?! xD

i felt pain because jacob felt pain.
poor jacob. =(

I don't know I really relate to evryone quite a lot (much more than I should), so a lot of it was painfull.

I hated this part! :(

i felt soo bad when jacob was howling after bella left for honeymoon. I wanted to find out what was wrong with him and stuff!!!

I cried so bad when Edward left- i still cry even now and ive read new moon over 20 times - seriously but its like i feel Edward and Bellas pain - i always feel depressed when he leaves and until he comes back in New Moon. And when Jake and Bella kissed I couldn't believe it - i was like OMG what is she thinking, throwing everything she has with Edward away, after everything hes done for her.I have always been able to relate to Bella and sometimes you can imagine yourself as her but when she Kissed jake I felt betrayed lol its sounds silly i know but i couldn't relate to Bella at all then and i was angry that she risked everything with Edward for Jake. The end of New Moon and Eclipse are happy, just like Twilight and Breaking Dawn, but New Moon as awhole was the most painful then Eclipse

I've read the book [New Moon] 17 times, & I've cried ALL those times. & I couldn't read till the next day, I was SO devastated.

When Edward left Bella in New Moon felt pain but still wanna read. But when When Bella Kissed Jacob in Eclipse, I just want to throw the book

i cried!!! :-(

I didn't find anything in the Twilight series devastating in the slightest because I didn't care about any of the characters.

iam team Jacob,so i think Eclipse was kinda hard to read,because Jake was much hurt in the book.

why do you hate bella i mean she is a good acter for her anf come on i mean there really going out

I cried when i watched The Twilight saga:New Moon;it was so devastating when Edward left Bella!!!!poor Bella!!!!!!!

I cried like a baby