Would you be mad if they changed New Moon by adding more Edward to the movie so Rob Pattinson could have a larger role? Poll Results - Twilight Series

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Twilight Series Would you be mad if they changed New Moon by adding more Edward to the movie so Rob Pattinson could have a larger role?

93 fans picked:

Yes. Stick to the book!

65%

No. I love Edward and Rob!

35%

itailianjr120 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

33 comments

	itailianjr120 picked Yes. Stick to the book!: as much as i would love to see rob on screen in new moon i would rather they stick to the book posted over a year ago.

	FlightofFantasy picked Yes. Stick to the book!: Come on, New Moon is about Edward being ABSENT and Bella's budding relationship with Jacob! Jacob and Taylor rule!!! :D posted over a year ago.

	x-Sophie-Jade-x picked Yes. Stick to the book!: they already have changed the script so that Edward is a bigger part, i love rob/edward but it is stupid that they are changing the story :( posted over a year ago.

	mayra7632000 picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: well it depends...i mean if they are going to add parts where they're showing what the cullens are doing while they are gone than yeah..sure why not..but if they show him during the bella and jacob parts...ummm no just keep him out like in the book posted over a year ago.

	mariabk picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: no not really posted over a year ago.

	firekeeper picked Yes. Stick to the book!: it is a good book so why should they change it becuse then we wouled not get to see jacob and bella become friends posted over a year ago.

	cheer_monkey picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: ok i picked no i loved edward and Rob but then i read the other comments and decided that its better to stick to the book posted over a year ago.

	Cittycat19 picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: As long it is close too the book I am happy but I like to see more of Edward posted over a year ago.

	Cee1901 picked Yes. Stick to the book!: Even though I adore Edward with all my fangirl heart, they shouldnt change the books. posted over a year ago.

	Team_Edward77 picked Yes. Stick to the book!: I think I would be a little upset casue he is gone when hes gone they cant change that it will just mess up everything :( posted over a year ago.

	Chimkmunk picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: no id be like "YES,YES YES!!!!" posted over a year ago.

	JACOBLOVR45 picked Yes. Stick to the book!: HELLLLL'S yeah i would be MAD!!!!!!!!!!! posted over a year ago.

	catherinexoxo6 picked Yes. Stick to the book!: they should stick to the story line. it's the right thing. might upset fans...if it doesn't turn out right. if you know what i mean. posted over a year ago.

	twilight_23 picked Yes. Stick to the book!: as much as i HATE jacob black, i really think they should stick to the book. i would be really disapointed if they just completely changed stephenie's work. posted over a year ago.

	dragonrider picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: I wouldn't be mad I would just be ok whatever posted over a year ago.

	tooch picked Yes. Stick to the book!: I wouldn't be mad, I just think they should stick to the book. It wouldn't be fair, to Stephenie Meyer especially, because she worked so hard writing these books. -xo. posted over a year ago.

	thisfiasco_ picked Yes. Stick to the book!: stick to the book. posted over a year ago.

	spikes_girl picked Yes. Stick to the book!: he's only going to be in two scenes, so actually less than the book. at least i think. posted over a year ago.

	falloutboy13 picked Yes. Stick to the book!: even though i really dont like new moon and really love edward/rob, if they changed the storyline, then it would be a little weird and it would kinda screw it up. i agree with tooch and twilight_23 posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	nosemuffin picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: Even though Jacob is my favorite character, I much dislike the casting of him.. so I have to say more Rob scenes are the way to go. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	rachaelwsz picked Yes. Stick to the book!: Stick to the book. LOuder STICK TO THE BOOK!!! As much as I love Edward, I really want them to stick to the book! After all, we'll be seeing a lot of Robert for the Eclipse and BD movies! posted over a year ago.

	twilightnesness picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: i would absoloutly LOVE it if edward was in it more. in my opinion new moon is one of the worst books ive ever read just because Edward(the best fictional character in the universe) is only in it for about 2 seconds beginning and end. And besides -sorry taylor, luv ya- i HATE jacob black compared to him. I so HOPE THEY HAVE HIM MORE IN THE MOVIE. The book was painful without him. And besides, RPATTZ is the hootest guy in the universe swoonage x posted over a year ago.

	Kaidi picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: Well, I think a bit more Edward wouldn't hurt, but only as long as they won't leave out something important from the book just so Robert could have a larger role. posted over a year ago.

	sweet_twilight picked Yes. Stick to the book!: Well I want them to stick to the book. But I love Edward and Rob too. I dont want them to cut any Edward time. But everyone has a point with adding the outtakes of NM which have Edward and the Cullens in. I still want them to stick to the book. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	s3ptamber picked Yes. Stick to the book!: BUT I LOVE ROBERT ! posted over a year ago.

	11Anime_Fool picked Yes. Stick to the book!: I mean NEW MOON IS ABOUT BELLA MISSING EDWARD! posted over a year ago.

	xPajax17 said: i dont know. i guess in a way i wouldnt lk it as much if they changed it a lot. but i cant decided posted over a year ago.

	Lau-rawr picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: I think they should mainly stick to the book But also i would like to see parts with Edward and the Cullens - to se what they're like when they're away but mainly stick to the book posted over a year ago.

	carly-hope picked Yes. Stick to the book!: I dont want additional Edward scenes. but I want all Edward scenes from the book. who cares about Jacob :) posted over a year ago.

	laureng114 picked Yes. Stick to the book!: just... STICK TO THE BOOK! don't mess with something good. posted over a year ago.

	Yama picked No. I love Edward and Rob!: I am definately a die-hard Edward fan. It's a hard choice for me, for the book is good but I definately love Edward too much to not see him in between... posted over a year ago.

	katiecain picked Yes. Stick to the book!: I really hope they don't add Edward/Cullens scenes of them away. It would show that Edward is missing Bella--which we shouldn't know until the end. posted over a year ago.

	katiecain picked Yes. Stick to the book!: link I just found this, I thought you guys might be interested in what Rob says about it :) Starts about 6:15. posted over a year ago.