Did you not like New Moon the most because it was really sad, or because edward wasn't there? Poll Results - Twilight Series

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Twilight Series Did you not like New Moon the most because it was really sad, or because edward wasn't there?

69 fans picked:

Edward wasn&# 39; t there

Edward wasn't there

46%

I actually liked New Moon

25%

(added by CoolMandyz43)

i love new moon : )

12%

(added by kelsey887)

i kinda liked it even though edward wasnt there

(added by padme768)

It was sad

Because I didn&# 39; t like how mellow it was, I still...

Because I didn't like how mellow it was, I still like it though

(added by Sweetiecheeks)

What happened to the passion, I mean Edward could...

What happened to the passion, I mean Edward could not even kiss bella with-out ge

(added by mmorgem)

codepink456 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

14 comments

It was sad

mayra7632000 picked It was sad:

i actually liked new moon...but the story was pretty sad..and finding out that jacob was a werewolf and bella's depression kind of made me forget about edward...but then he came back!=D ..though i didnt like that he left

posted over a year ago.

I actually liked New Moon

mari_giovani picked I actually liked New Moon:

Yeah, i also liked New Moon!! And i agree with mayra7632000!!! :)

posted over a year ago.

Edward wasn&# 39; t there

leuron picked Edward wasn't there:

As I don't like Jacob Black I read New Moon always expecting for Edward to appear again.. gosh it was kinda hard reading most of the book...

posted over a year ago.

I actually liked New Moon

CoolMandyz43 picked I actually liked New Moon:

That's why I just added that choice of liking New Moon. I liked learning about Jacob even though Im a die heart Team Edward, while I was reading it, it made me think that Bella could be with Jacob and be happy. But believe me I was happy when Edward was back lol!! I loved when they were back together!

posted over a year ago.

Edward wasn&# 39; t there

jackiehyde4eva picked Edward wasn't there:

Dont get me wrong i do like New Moon its a good book buts its my least fav of the series i didnt like that Edward and the cullens weren't there plus it was sad! im also a strong team edward but i did like the storyline with jacob and i love Jake and bella as friends but i was so excited when the cullens came back

posted over a year ago.

Edward wasn&# 39; t there

spikes_girl picked Edward wasn't there:

two words: jacob black.

posted over a year ago.

Edward wasn&# 39; t there

AliceC picked Edward wasn't there:

I TOTALLY AGREE leuron.I ACTUALLY SKIPPED A COUPLE OF PAGES AHEAD TO LOOKE FOR EDWARD'S NAME!AND YES I DID CRY WHEN HE LEFT,INFACT I THREW THE BOOK DOWN AND SCEAMED "YOU BEAUTIFUL,SON OF A BITCH!".YEAH...

posted over a year ago.

I actually liked New Moon

Phaedra picked I actually liked New Moon:

Can you believe it? xD
I really don't get why people wouldn't like it because 'someone' isn't actually there... It's not as if he's not still an important part of the book or something... Bella still talks/thinks about the Cullens...
And even if that weren't the case, I'd still like the book, it was so... real... not the wolf-things, but the rest... yeah...

posted over a year ago.

Edward wasn&# 39; t there

richie_respati picked Edward wasn't there:

da reason dat i love to read twilight saga becoz of Edward and Bella' romance... so when Edward wasn't there,, i didn't like it too much, and i'd pass the pages which was tell about Jacob

posted over a year ago.

I actually liked New Moon

sweet_twilight picked I actually liked New Moon:

If you would have asked me after the first time I read it, I would have probably picked because Edward wasnt there. But reading it the second time, I understood it more. I thought the book was very honest and real, agreeing with Phaedra. And I agree with mayra7632000 that it was sad. I guess the honesty and reality of things had an affect on me and I could kinda relate to her, especially when she was depressed, it was very deep! I also agree with CoolMandyz43, liked learning about Jacob but still I'm a die-hard Team Edward fan!

posted over a year ago.

I actually liked New Moon

kava picked I actually liked New Moon:

yes, i totally agree with phaedra. new moon is a very good book. i loved it, actually. it was so deep, interesting to read, interesting to feel that depression that bella felt... it was not just cheap "forbidden love" romance. no offence, i love whole twilight saga!! but it was definitely an awsome experience reading it.that's funny, but i didn't even miss edward!! xD

posted over a year ago.

I actually liked New Moon

laureng114 picked I actually liked New Moon:

of course you missed edward but..
if he never left then we wouldnt of realized how much edward and bella need eachother.
im not on team jacob but im glad he was in the story.
hes genuine and during new moon had no intention of making bella do anything she did not want to.
i really enjoyed new moon.

posted over a year ago.

Edward wasn&# 39; t there

xtwilightxx picked Edward wasn't there:

half way through the book i startd screaming 'WHERES EDWARD?'

posted over a year ago.

What happened to the passio- n,...

mmorgem picked What happened to the passion, I mean Edward could not even kiss bella with-out ge:

Liked new moon, but missed the romance and passion between Edward and Bella.. I just didnt feel it, like he would get thrown up against a wall when he kissed bella...they have this chemistry that the movie really didnt bring out or should I say Jacob didnt bring out in Bella.

posted over a year ago.

Add Your Comment

Twilight Series

Twilight Series Did you not like New Moon the most because it was really sad, or because edward wasn't there?

14 comments

Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment

Twilight Series more polls