First, he's a fictional character, so even though he's described as insanely beautiful I have like absolutely no idea what he looks like, unless I imagine it... and obviously, like everyone else, I imagine him insanely good looking :) But, even though he's a great boyfriend and all that, he's got some pretty bad qualities, which takes away some of my interest for him. Like, he's got some temper and the only person I've actually read him being SUPER nice to is Bella... and he's insanely protective... and his chaaracter is so static. He doesn't change, and he has absolutely zero flaws. He was just written because he was Stephenie Meyer's fantasy... and I mean, I'd like someone with a little background.
Don't get me wrong, I LIKE Edward... I just don't think he's that hot(personality wise), and I know I am like WAY over analyzing this pick (because it probably was just made for people to say if he's good looking or not) but I tend to always over- voice my opinion, so sorry about that :)

he isnt a fictional character because he is in twilight and he is going to mabey make the athouer movies

^^ Ummm... just because an actor played him in a movie doesn't make Edward Cullen suddenly a non-fictional character.
If we are talking about Robert Pattinson (who is a real person) that would be a different story... but the pick said "Edward Cullen" who is a fictional character.

well with the description of him in the book, the way i picture him in my head, yes, he is hot! and he is hot in the movie, even though that's rob.
i understand what you're saying 1treehillfan, but why is it that so many have a people have a problem with a flawless character? that's just the way stephanie writes him as, and if he's her fantasy, well, i don't mind cuz he's my fantasy too :)

^^ I see where your coming from, but it bothers me because ral people aen't flawless. Therefore, he just isn't real to me. And that bothers me that he is so unreal... it sets kind of a bad example for people... because love isn't like that. If there is love at all. There are no Edward Cullens in the world.