Didi you hear about the comment about Breaking Dawn by a suppose "fan". They said, "don't burn them, return them!" Poll Results - Twilight Series

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Twilight Series Didi you hear about the comment about Breaking Dawn by a suppose "fan". They said, "don't burn them, return them!"

66 fans picked:

No.

50%

Yes.

32%

Well I heard about the book burning but not...

Well I heard about the book burning but not that...

(added by Sweetiecheeks)

what?

(added by kelsey887)

kayem91 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

18 comments

	ilurvedward picked No.: we should burn HIM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! that's horrible!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! posted over a year ago.

	monkee95 picked Yes.: yes, i was reading the comments people wrote in that thread. It was really harsh. It has really hurt Stephenie. I feel badly for her! I loved Breaking Dawn! :) posted over a year ago.

	courick11 picked No.: wow that's really mean. I really loved Breaking Dawn!! It was so fantastic! posted over a year ago.

	katyownsyouxx picked Yes.: Sad thing is, I can see why people would think things like that, even though I don't fully agree. posted over a year ago.

	CullenCult picked No.: Could someone leave a link to it, so that the people who haven't could read it? please! posted over a year ago.

	Iheartedward picked Yes.: that is ridiculous I think these people are not true fans if they were they would not say that and respect stephenie meyer for the genius that she is. posted over a year ago.

	vampiressparkle picked Yes.: I don't understand what everyone's problems are. She wrote an awesome book. If you don't like it, whatever. Each to his or her own. But they really didnt need to say such mean and hurtful things. She's a genius. I will read anything she writes. posted over a year ago.

	kateliness2 picked No.: That's silly. I liked the book overall. It wasn't my favorite of the series, but I did like it. What a mean, mean thing to say. posted over a year ago.

	mrz17 picked Yes.: Whoever that person is...he's a hell of an idiot. It really makes me mad when people criticize things as if they know better. It is because of Stephanie the reason why we are all enthralled with Twilight. We should be grateful for that. ...hmmm... Maybe not everyone's happy with Edward having his new Mrs. Cullen, or Jacob imprinting on Renesmee (love that name : > ), cause that means they are no longer available to most of us...even though they are just fictional characters... ...I'm serious about the first part...the second part is meant to be a joke... posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	arw7792 picked Yes.: that's stupid. Stepenie is amazing! Breaking Dawn wasn't my favorite book but that's a mean thing to say. I dont think i can read another book without comparing it to the Twilight saga and I'm sure they wont even compare. I read the host and it was awesome too. she is like the best writer. posted over a year ago.

	Gabitha picked No.: No i didn't hear that, but its very rude! I think anyway posted over a year ago.

	christineadkins picked No.: thats so horrible! it wasnt my top fav out of the whole saga but i loved them all. she has such a wonderful talent! all of her books rock and i cant wait til a new book by her comes out. that person should be ashamed. everyone has an opinion, yeah, but you shouldnt be hurtful about it. posted over a year ago.

	cm01 picked No.: thats pretty low! thats not just a comment its like a stab at the author! which is just wrong like if u dont like the book take it out some other way.. posted over a year ago.

	redkie picked Yes.: i read about it wich i thot was realy stupid i havent red breaking dawn yet but just becuase they didint like the way the book ended they shouldint throw a hisy fit its stefeny meyers story she can end it how she wants too! posted over a year ago.

	CullenCult picked No.: Again, could someone, who HAS read it please leave the link to it in a comment... PLEASE!!! I want to read it before I judge... posted over a year ago.

	s3ptamber picked No.: why people didn't like it? isn't this stupid? the book was absolutely amazing.. that's one of my favorite though posted over a year ago.

	duckey94 picked No.: Whoa, I never heard that until I googled it and found it on Amazon. Huh. I suppose it's an effective way to protest if they really don't like the book. I mean, it's certainly not one of my favorite books, but that doesn't mean I'd burn it or return it. posted over a year ago.

	vianessvondrak picked Yes.: i heard those comments and really think they are very childish!! the book was amazind, maybe the better of all. i understand everybody has a different point of view and if you didnt like it is ok, but saying that was really bad!!! many people dont even have a good argument why thwy didnt like it, so??? posted over a year ago.