I think he was a good choice, but I liked Jacob before, and all of these answers are for Jacob haters; which I'm not. I'm not an Edward hater either, I like both of them. So, I don't think I'll answer the question..

i agree with timbitzk...but i went ahead and answered lol

in my opinion he is a good choice for jacob...but what about when they do sequels? like he is supposed to be like super buff and freakishly tall lol so how are they gonna pull that off??

I agree too. I couldn't like Jake anymore, Taylor was just such an added bonus

Steven Strait would have been better..

None of those answers really fit the question in my opinion. I think Taylor looks just like Jacob but it doesn't make me like him more or less.

It is hardly possible for me to like Jake more than I do ;)

And I think he's a good choice for young Jacob :)

I've hated Jacob since I read New Moon. Eclipse made my hate stronger. Breaking Dawn made it die down a little bit... But I still hate him.

At first i really wanted steven strait to be jacob but now after seeing all the interviews with Taylor Lautner im really happy, he has the cutest smile and an AMAZING body perfect for jacob ;)