Honestly, as of right now because New Moon hasn't come out yet, I don't think we should consider him yet as someone who could be a possibility for Breaking Dawn. I mean yeah the trailers and tv spots are all pretty cool. But we can't base it off of them. Any one can make trailers, half of the fans here think that the fan made trailer are awesome. And look at Catherine Hardwicke, everyone wanted her to direct New Moon, not after Twilight I'll tell you that. My point is I think we should see the movie to actually answer this question.