answer this question

Twilight Series Question

im confused is jacob a bad guy?

 eclipse4 posted over a year ago
next question »

Twilight Series  best answer

mandapanda said:
Jacob the character or the werewolves? To me, Jacob nor the werewolves are "bad guys". The werewolves only exist for one purpose. It's to protect people from vampires. So, if we are pointing out who "bad guys" are, then I have to say vampires, even though I like them better. Technically, i wouldn't even call them "bad guys".

Neither species, shapeshifter or vampire chose their path. They didn't choose to become what they are. It just happened. The vampires in the series are sometimes portrayed as the bad guys. But, honestly, if you were bitten, it not being your choice, it's inevitable. Vampires nature is to drink blood. That's what makes the Cullens stronger, maybe not physically, but mentally. The Cullens use what was given to them to the best of their ability. They try and live better than what their kind is known for. And since they claimed to be different, that's when the wolves and Cullens formed the treaty. A truce as long as the Cullens don't kill on the land.

I don't say Jacob or the werewolves are the bad guys, even though i don't care for the wolves or Jacob, but neither are the Cullens. I consider the Cullens to be in a completely different league than newborns.

ps. sorry if i didn't explain too well. this is that type of situation where you know what the answer is, you just can't put it into words. lol
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
oooooo yaaaaa
kittykelly posted over a year ago
next question »

Answers

akasha_5th said:
No, definetly not! He is hot, sexy, mostly moral, but most importantly truelly in LOVE.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
kareinabambina said:
i don't think so. i think his reactions are typical for someone who is his age. he doesn't always make the best decisions, but i think he's a good guy who sometimes acts his age. it's easy to think he's a bad guy because of some of the things he says and does, and when you compare jacob to edward -- edward seems to always want bella to be happy, whereas jacob seems to want the same, but jacobs wants his own happiness too.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
bellasommers said:
it actually really depends on what side you are on.. are you a vamp or a shapeshifer (werewolf). but in the eyes of everyone in the book he is the annoying one that need to get off of bellas d.c lol but ya but in the movie he is ohh soo sexy! but yea it really depends. in an overall it is up to you to decide wether u like him or not and believe that he is bad.. but read breaking dawn (if you havent) he helps so in a whole no.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
JenoJake said:
Jacob is absolutely not a bad guy.On the contrary he's a great guy who loves a girl ( which doesn't deserve his love ) and fights like hell to gain hers. He has the right to do so. He let Bella be her self not like Edward who's always controlling her. He's like a control freak. He sacrificed his youth to protect people of vampires. I totally love him.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i don't believe jacob sacrificed his youth. he didn't have a choice in the matter. when he first found out what he was, jacob wasn't pleased with his predicament.
kareinabambina posted over a year ago
*
I didn't say he sacrificed his YOUTH but he sacrificed way much more than that . He sacrificed his heart , his friends , his father , his pack and the most important thing his life to defend Bella and the Collins so many times
JenoJake posted over a year ago
*
I totally agree with you, JenoJake! Team Jacob forever!
americanhoney posted over a year ago
*
thanks team Jacob for sure ;-)
JenoJake posted over a year ago
cr6zym0nkeyiz said:
jacob is not a bad guy. i think why people say they hate jacob or whteva is b/c of the whole edward bella & jacob love triangle. and they want bella to be wit edward and hate some of the things that jacob does. buh he's not the bad guy he's one of the good guys.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
rino25 said:
noooooooo his vey beautiful and cute i love him
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
americanhoney said:
Technically, no, Jacob isn't a bad guy. But I guess it all depends on your personal opinion. I'm sure some of the Team Edward fans view Jacob as a bad guy because he kinda got in the way of Edward/Bella's relationship. However, I'm a proud member of Team Jacob, and I view Edward as the bad guy. I guess it all depends.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »