who was like wanting to punch Edward when he said he didnt want Bella anymore???

For all those who hate Edward because he left her, it's unjustified.

First off, He left to protect her from what he is. Re-read chapter 22 of Eclipse. The 4 options he explained to Jacob explains why he did what he did and how it hurt him.

Second, for those who are saying Jacob never left Bella. Um, He did. He left her when he had to keep his secret. And guess what? He left her to protect her.

So in other words, they both left her to protect her. But Jacob never did was Edward did. Edward let Bella have her choice. And her choice was Edward. Jacob, however, emotionally blackmailed her and mouthraped her in Eclipse.

I'm not accusing people of liking Jacob, I'm just frustrated with those that fail to realize Jacob did leave Bella, just like Edward did, and those who are reluctant to accept the fact that Edward did the things he did to protect her.

me! i hate that he leave her. i hate him after that,and i cant like him again either. Jacob is a much better person that Edward ever will be.

i luv jacob hes so cute

I knew Edward was lying to just protect her. He had already said several times that he would if he put her in danger. You can't blame him for everything.

So Me!!!

i totally wanted to bet the shit out of edward for leaving bella. but i got iver ut because i knew that bella could go to jacob now!!!

i hated to see her suffer so much...her trauma was really pathetic...i really hated edward when he said that...damn, i wanted to punch him so bad, but that would only break my hand..Lol..
Although i lyk Jacob better dan Edward still i dont think that wasn the right way to keep bella protected...Edward acted lyk a moron!!