i was reading page 483. when it says(we didnt have to catch our breath or eat or even use the bathroom.we had no more mundane human needs. now my question. if they have no need to use the rest room or human needs than how is edward able to get bella p

mandapanda said:

well, I would try Stephenie Meyer's website. She explains it.

But I disagree with her explanation. There's really no rational way to explain what too place in Breaking Dawn except that Stephenie Meyer tried to make things too complicated.

I honestly don't know what to say about Breaking Dawn anymore. It just raises questions and they don't have answers. Stephenie Meyer may provide her answers, but it doesn't make sense, and it's contradictory to what she's said in the past about her vampires and how they don't have fluids.

"How does Edward have sperm?"
"How did he get her pregnant?"

There's no rational explanation. If you want to hear it from Stephenie Meyer, I suggest taking a look at her website. the FAQ section at link It's about 2/3rds down the page. :)

For those who disagree, please don't judge me. It's just my opinion of the book. Everytime I read it, I find more flaws. So, please don't yell at me for not liking Breaking Dawn :)

posted over a year ago

same here!!

Brysis posted over a year ago

thanks do u have any more flaws u found?

theresap86 posted over a year ago

Hiding 5 comments... click to show.

when I say flaws I mean flaws in my opinion, not structural flaws. But the flaws I found in the book is how the characters were. They were completely different from the other 3 previous books. If you read Eclipse and Breaking Dawn back to back, the characters are completely different, Edward especially. And in BD, I remember reading about the prophecies of a half vampire/human baby being born. Since when did SM incorporate prophecies in her world? This entire time, throughout the books, she's had the characters say time and time again that the stereotype of the vampires and werewolves are inaccurate. But she contradicts herself when bringing the prophecy into the story. Made no sense. lol

mandapanda posted over a year ago

i just went to her web site and read on human and vampire fluids. in bd bella says they no longer have mudanne human needs. human fluids. i had to read it three times but now i understand. she says vampires have many different types of venimous

theresap86 posted over a year ago

fluids . that helps their bodys function. the other fluids that are not venums she dosent have a name for it but its like sperm and carries their gennitic traits and is compatable with human eggs. so thats how she was able to get pregnant.so its not sperm.but much the same.

theresap86 posted over a year ago

lol

theresap86 posted over a year ago

i mean, I can understand what she's saying, it just doesn't make sense. lol rationally it doesn't... BD is mythical with the vampire/human baby, whereas her other 3 books, although vampires/werewolves were included, they dealt with real life issues. BD does not. I'm still irritated with Breakind Dawn but I can't really do anything about it. lol

mandapanda posted over a year ago

Once again, mandapanda says what I'm too afraid to say on here (how it's contradictory) XD I agree, she's said all these things in the past and then she goes back on it all.

katiecain posted over a year ago

MorningSong said:

On page 483 isn't Bella already a vampire so she can't get pregnant. She was pregnant earlier when she was a human!

posted over a year ago

yeah but if vampires dont have human fluids how can edward have sperm in which to get bella pregnant?

theresap86 posted over a year ago

nice words there, I said ew when I read, but you both have a point! Stephanie probaby forgot what she wrote and she probably would answer on her website, and if not her myspace! Yes, she has a myspace

BuffyFaithFan1 posted over a year ago

Hiding 3 comments... click to show.

because boys are the same from puberty to manhood and it fiction thts how

robynm posted over a year ago

Ednbella said:

let me ask another question relating to human fluids . i'd like to know with all the blood they drink where would that go ? into their dead tissue of skin? i mean we loose blood through urine and monthlys and stuff its just a weird question?

posted over a year ago

i think i would be used into energy thats why if they dont feed their weak. it probly sits into their bodys until its absorbed for energy. in bd after bella gets done feeding she explains that she feels sloshy from all the blood she drank. so its like us when we eat to much.

theresap86 posted over a year ago

we need blood for other purposes they only need it for energy

theresap86 posted over a year ago

the venom in their system probably absorbs it...

lauracullen66 posted over a year ago

naley_fan said:

I`ve questioned myself this many times. And i have never managed to find the answer.

posted over a year ago

her web site under bd faqs u might have to read it a few times i know idid she called it a sperm like .but not sperm.

theresap86 posted over a year ago

yeah,i`ve read it already. but still i find it inexplicable.

naley_fan posted over a year ago

chagrin91 said:

i also think how bella got pregnant i mean if rosalie n esme cant have babies coz dy dont have periods thn i think dis whole sperm thing is boys periods sooo how did she get pregnant????? dont noe bt SM have to explain tat to her fans..............

posted over a year ago

i found the answer last night on her web site. she says they dont have blood or human fluids. but they have venumous fluids to replace those.they have some fluids that are not venumes. she says its like sperm but she dosent call it that. it carries their genettic traits so it almost the same as sperm.and its compatable with female human eggs. thats why she got pregnant.

theresap86 posted over a year ago

rose and esmes bodys cant change in order to carrie a babie because its frozen in the state in which they changed in to a vampire

theresap86 posted over a year ago

Hiding 4 comments... click to show.

i still dont get it but thankx for da ans lolzzzzzz ...............................=) peace

chagrin91 posted over a year ago

gemma1906 said:

Putting aside the sperm issue...which Stephenie Myer seems to be able to explain, anyway, if vampires don't have blood or circulation, then it wouldn't be possible for them to get an erection. They wouldn't even be able to have sex.
But remembering this is just a story...who cares if it makes sense? It is about mythical vampires, after all - that's pretty much creative licence to write whatever you want.

posted over a year ago

i agree with u but still its kind of impossible...........

chagrin91 posted over a year ago

I also wondered about that, but i figured that since his body was hard like stone that it applied to every paart of his body/...i know ...weird but with so many unanswered questions one has to make up her own theories

Diana8701 posted over a year ago

she explains how he can get aroused. like i said i had to read it 3 times befor i understood it all

theresap86 posted over a year ago

shes a really smart women she thought of everything

theresap86 posted over a year ago

Taylor Lautner	Twilight Movie	Robert Pattinson
Edward Cullen	Kristen Stewart	Jacob Black
Alice Cullen	Edward and Bella	Bella Swan

Twilight Series

Twilight Series Question

Twilight Series Answers

Twilight Series Related Clubs