Twilight Series Question

(new moon spoiler ) about when Bella went cliff diving .

so .... when Edward thought that bells was dead and decided to kill him self why would he go to Italy and ask the Voultri to kill him ..

he could just buy a gas tank and burned him self to death ... that would have done the job easier and faster ..

I mean don't get me wrong . I like the story the way it is , it just doesn't make sense ..

in breaking down when he was talking with Bella about Alec's ability he said that sometimes the Voultri didn't bother to cut vampires into pieces before they killed them they just burn them while they are blind and numb .. so that works right ..

and it must hurt less than being choped up and then burned !!

A-D posted over a year ago

next question »

Twilight Series Answers

shellycane said:

Well from my point of view, Edward couldnt care less if it was painful for him to die or not. The biggest pain for him is losing Bella (which he thinks happened). So no matter if there would be a better way for him, he always would choose the Volturi. He knows full well that none of his family would help him to die, and he is a rather classic and old fashioned guy. So that appears to be the only making sense way, if you ask me.

posted over a year ago

yeah it totally makes sense, he couldn't exsist without her =]

irunwithcullens posted over a year ago

I am glad i dont have that opinion alone. I mean thats the way i figured he would feel :D btw hi TWILIGHTER

shellycane posted over a year ago

Hiding 7 comments... click to show.

But going to the Voultri will actually endanger his family right .. in Breaking Down The Voultri's decision has already been made to come after the cullens once they had any reason .. that's because Aro knows about Edward and Alice's ability and he wanted them on his side .. that wouldn't have happend if Edward didn't go to the Voultri in new moon right ?

A-D posted over a year ago

I would have understood if he attacked the Voultri and killed as much as he could can of him before he dies .. THAT would be Classic and Old Fashioned not just asking them kindly to kill him don't you agree ?

A-D posted over a year ago

At this point my dear, that was for sure not a problem for him. First things first, he is different to Bella.- knowing his family can take care of himself. Second sharing the past that Carlisle and The Volturi do, that problem didnt appear at all. And i am not mind reader [for Stephenie Meyer] but if it wasnt for Bella, the Cullens and the Volturi probably would have never had problems at all. To get back at your question, i still stick to what is aid. Simple as that we didnt discuss if Edward was doing the right or wrong thing, we dicussed if there was an other way that made sense for him. <3

shellycane posted over a year ago

But the character of Edward is not harsh, or straight forward or unkind. So that wouldnt have made sense for him. Again. So when i say classic and old fashioned then i mean for him. The way he is through the whole Twilight Saga. Something you mean would be like Emmet might do it, then again he isnt the kind for suicide.

shellycane posted over a year ago

I think I understand your point now .. and the Voultri wouldn't want the cullens dead so badly if it wasn't for bella ... thank you for your time ..

A-D posted over a year ago

Your welcome, i am glad we understand each other :D

shellycane posted over a year ago

me too :)

A-D posted over a year ago

yea I would do the same if I was a vampire and lost the one that was my life

vampirefreak_26 posted over a year ago

Flickerflame said:

Possibly being cut up first has some sort of numbing effect. Or maybe he thought that once he'd be on fire, his instincts would drive him to try to extinguish it regardless of actual suicidal intent - when Alec had paralysed a vampire's senses they'd be less able to extinguish the fire, but one with full senses would be co-ordinated enough to do so.

posted over a year ago

next question »

Taylor Lautner	Twilight Movie	Robert Pattinson
Edward Cullen	Kristen Stewart	Jacob Black
Alice Cullen	Edward and Bella	Bella Swan

Twilight Series

Twilight Series Question

(new moon spoiler ) about when Bella went cliff diving .

Twilight Series Answers

Twilight Series Related Clubs