answer this question

Twilight Series Question

what did edward mean when he said "carlisle was right" in new moon?

this is the part where bella is in italy and finally reaches edward in the alley and prevents him from walking out into the sun..and when edward sees her he says that quote..do you guys know what he meant by it?

thanks =)
 mayra7632000 posted over a year ago
next question »

Twilight Series  best answer

katlynncore said:
edward didn't believe that he could go to heaven (being a vampire and all). but when he saw bella, he thought the volturi had killed him, and that he was in heaven with bella. earlier in the book, carlisle was telling bella that he believed that vampires could go to heaven, and that he didn't think they were soulless the way edward did.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »

Answers

Ginnylyne said:
Rosalie told him Bella was dead and he thinks the Volturi already killed him. Carlisle said that they kill you fast.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
i_luv_jacob101 said:
Edward believed that when he saw Bella he was in heaven...and earlier in the book carlisle said that vampires could go to heaven.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
hajer said:
edward always thought that he will end up in hell becuz he had lost his soul when he changed into a vampire but carlisle always thought it dependes on what you do if it's good you will go to heaven and if it's bad you will go to hell,so when edward went to italy to kill him self after he thought that bella is dead ,he thought they both met in the other life or in another word Heaven ,so he thought carlisle is right !long story right ? can't keep it short!
select as best answer
edward always thought that he will end up in hell becuz he had lost his soul when he changed into a vampire but carlisle always thought it dependes on what you do if it's good you will go to heaven and if it's bad you will go to hell,so when edward went to italy to kill him self after he thought that bella is dead ,he thought they both met in the other life or in another word Heaven ,so he thought carlisle is right !long story right ? can't keep it short!
posted over a year ago 
opalrose said:
he was saying that vampires do have an afterlife that carlisle was right!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »