Twilight Series

answer this question

Twilight Series Question

Do you think that Charlie has a right to know that Bella is a Vampire? And do you think bella is hypocrite?

Or should she keep him in the dark? I still think that she shouldn't tell him because then he would have to be a Vampire and thats not bella would have chosen for him. But thats what Edward thought about bella, so wouldn't that make bella a hypocrite and she should have known that if she was Edward she wouldn't have wanted herslef to have this life.... Im confusing myself now......
 Renesmee-C-C posted over a year ago
next question »

Twilight Series Answers

summerfrog said:
that is confusing but it makes since.I always felt bad for Charlie because everyone around him knew except him so I think he deserves to know-especially now that he has a granddaughter!
and now that I think of it Bella is not being a hypocrite because Charlie doesn't really know about the vampires-only sort of-to be around Renesmee
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
MsEdwardCullen2 said:
No Charlie should not know because then there would be questions about like how why when who and etc. and she can't lie about that then the Cullens would be reveled then they would have to again! Bella's not a hypocrite, where did you draw that conclusion(not in a mean way at all!!!) cause i don't think she is a hypocrite.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Hellohoudini said:
Read Breaking Dawn...things work out for everyone
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I have read it! and thats what so confusing!
Renesmee-C-C posted over a year ago
*
lol...Charlie is one of those people who can function on a "need to know basis"..Jacob helped him see that other things are possible..so Charlie being a smart man knows that something is different about Edward and now Bella and Nessie but because he loves them so much...he is willing to leave it at "they're here..they're safe and thats all I need to know"..... does that help any?
Hellohoudini posted over a year ago
Phaedra said:
He has a right to know, but he shouldn't be informed of it. I mean... Sure, he deserves to know it, but since the Volturi kind of want the Cullens dead already...
When Bella was with Edward in their city, they wanted to kill her, because she was 'in the know', unless they planned to make her a vampire too. Only Alice's vision saved her there.
If they were to find out that Charlie knew about vampires too, they wouldn't just kill him, probably. They'd have another excuse for killing the Cullens. (I know Bella's shield scared them off, but the desire of wanting them dead would not go away, as I believe was mentioned in BD too)
So, it's not worth it. Charlie's better off not knowing too much, they all are...

I do not believe Bella is a hypocrite, they are doing the right thing by not telling him.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
But if bella does not want that for Charlie than that makes her a hypocrite, no? Because Edward didn't want that for bella.
Renesmee-C-C posted over a year ago
*
The situation is completely different with Charlie...
Phaedra posted over a year ago
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!