Who's gift is more useful Alice's or Edward's?

i would say their powers r both equally important

Edward's. He can use it on more people, has immediate benefits, is not as open to interpretation, is more set in stone and he has more control over it.

I thing both as alice tells the future and Edward can read minds which is good cos if sumones lying he knows

alice sees the future

edward's is because alices visions change depending if the person changes their mind like she always says the future isn't set in stone.

i would say Edwards,because Alices power is subjective,it could change whenever a person changed their minds.

mmmmmmmmm i can't decide they are both good!

Edward

I think both of their powers are different nd useful...........But if i hv to go fr one i vl say edward's......alice's visions are basically subjective nd cn change

I say Edward. Even if Alice does see the future, Edward can read her mind to see what it is. Same with Aro.

i think alices cause she can see the future and edward can read minds

I would say Edward since he can read minds and can figure out what Alice's visions are. And if he can read minds, he can probably add up something close to the future like Alice.

Alice's because you don't need to read minds (I think reading minds is kind a stupid) but anyways i think Alice's power is the most important!

both are equally as important. Alice can stop things in the faraway future and Edward can encourage or stop things in the near future. personally i love jaspers gift of emotion changes.

On one hand Alice's is more importaint then again say you get in a fight then Edward's. It all depends on what that special gift is.

Alice's is more useful! she can see what will happen... so she has a heads up.. Edward can only know what is happening.

Alice

i thinh both

Edward!!!!!!!:D

I think Edward's power is slightly more useful, because it has less weaknesses/less people are immune to it. The only exception to Edward's mind reading we've seen is Bella's mental shield. Alice can't see the future of anyone of a species she hasn't been/can't be, like the werewolves or the human-vampire hybrids, and people can also evade her foresight by continually changing their plans.