For those who did NOT like Breaking Dawn, what problem did you have with the book, and how would you have wanted it?

Well first I would like to repeat your words: This isn't to bash Breaking Dawn
This isn't to bash Breaking Dawn
This isn't to bash Breaking Dawn

I'm not so sure yet if I liked the book or not, though I'm sure that it wasn't what I expected, I mean the characters were like very different from the other books and I still feel like it's missing something, maybe a battle, I was like "I waited 7 months to read THIS".

the edward offering bella to jacob (in that way) part.

I think that EVRRYONE should have LOVED Breaking Dawn!!! Whoever didn't....wow...how stupid!!!

I wouldn't say I didn't like all of it, but I'll name a few things I didn't like. First off, Jacob imprinting on Nessie. To me that was an easy way out of the love triangle. It was obvious that Smeyer had to find a way to get rid of Jacob so that Bella and Edward could have their happy ending.

Another thing was the thwarted battle scene between the Volturi and the vampire-werewolf alliance. It was totally anti-climactic and so not what I expected from the Volturi. I mean if you're going to create cool villains like that then you may as well use that for action. I was disappointed to see that there was no battle, and the Volturi simply gave in. Very unbelievable and anticlimactic.

But the thing I dislike the most about BD is that it's the last book (not counting MS which was never published as a book). I wanted to keep reading about what happens after BD. Grrrrrrr!

I loved Breaking Dawn! The only thing that I didn't like was Jacob imprinting on Renesmee, that was kind of weird.

I loved Breaking Dawn, especially the idea of half vampires. But I don't like Jacob imprinting of Renesmee. I mean, Edward was once his romantic rival and now he's his father-in-law? That's just... wrong, even when they don't age. And I was hoping for a battle between the Volturi and the Cullens. I got really disappointed that there wasn't a huge, epic battle.

I loved Breaking Dawn, It was my favorite book! Becuase of Renesmee and the wedding, the honey moon and just everything!

BUT!!

I was disapointed that they didnt have a fight at the end, If SM wasn't planning on writting another book after Breaking Dawn, ((Not Like MidNight Sun)) I mean to carry on after Breaking Dawn then I thought a better ending would be to have Edward+Bella die together,

I was only disapointed with that one bit! But I loved the rest of the book ;)

Overall, I thought the book was OK, but pretty boring. There were many things I didn't like; Jacob imprinting on Renesmee (I just find that whole thing extremely weird), the 'battle' which was not a battle at all, the Volturi gave up way too easily and it just made them lose all scariness they might have had and I didn't really like the fact that Edward and Bella had a kid (I prefered it with just them).

Also, the style of the writing seemed completely different! It didn't seem to fit with the other books. And Bella's whole personality seemed to change too.

I did however love all of Book 1, the wedding and honeymoon was beatuiful, and I really enjoyed reading Jacob's POV.

Yes,me too I don't want to bash Breaking Dawn,just to say why I didn't like it.
*First of all it isn't that I don't love Twilight series,but Breaking Dawn is the least favourite book to me.I didn't like the fact that Bella married with Edward and got pregnant so fastly and suddenly she became from a-teenaged-girl-who-has-just-graduated-hight-school,she became a good wife and an overprotective momma,which the onl two things she had in her mind were
*Making love with Edaward
*Keeping safe her daughter every time she remembered it of course

*****Again I don't want to offend someone who love Bd,or Nessie...

*Then I didn't like that much that the book was in parts,and I was really dissapointed when Bella became a vamp,I didn't imagine her like that.Like the only thing she needs is Edward!I didn't like that.Also the only action in the book was nearly in the end.All the rest of the book was a bit boring.
*Finally when Jacob imprints on Bella's daughter, however, he is stripped of his feelings for Bella forever. After he imprints on Renesmee he just loves Bella as his best friend.Where are all the strong feelings of him for Bella gone?Here you can tell me that all the fellings of him weren't real but still I don't found it logical.

I Liked BD I Wouldnt Of Changed Anything But the Battle which face it It really wasnt a battle at all i would have put more action at least let kate shock caius a little bit an things get a little raddled up and out of nowhere calm down when alice & jasper showed up (cause of jasper)and the same entrance when edward announced them.

I´m Team Jacob and it would be great, when Bella choose Jake in the last moment. And that Jake imprinted on Nessie was so wierd. And at the end the know that Nessie always will be young too. Everyone was happy than but it was not the best and we can´t change it. I don´t want to say that I don´t like Breaking dawn, but my favorite is Eclipse ;)

okaiexz...well i liked breaking dawn, buh it was mai least favorite of the 4 books. wht i didnt like was dat the whole jacob POV part of the book. i didnt like reading that part....i was like i cant wait til dis jacob part is over...dont get meh wrong i like jacob buh i didnt like it it was supposed to be the part in the book during bella's pregnancy so like they shouldve had it in her POV or edwards b/c we all knoe that he was feeling so sad that he mite loose her.

i also felt that like when the book was almost over that it was rushed. why too rushed. like no fight or anything at the end felt like....i dunno. buh i hated that....i liked pretty much everything else. oh. wait. stephanie meyer could have wrote more of a bed scene....it like there in bed now on to the next morning...WTF...come on!!!!! she couldve wrote a little more than that. it didnt have to be too descriptive buh she couldve wrote a least something.....and they were talking about the BD movie how that it will be steamy just like the book...HA! it wasnt steamy at all...what was steamy is us having to imagine more without her actually writing anything about the bed scene... LOL