Was Edward Fake Playing The Piano In The Movie Twilight ?

no. rob is a musician and does know how to play and it is in the DVD extras...you probally have the dvd with 2 discs...buh its in the special edition 3 discs..i think you can find it on youtube also.

He was playing...Catherine Hardwick had said it during an interview and I think they do talk about it during the commentary on the dvd.

For those who doesn't know, Robert plays the guitar and piano, and composes his own music.

He did say before when he was asked about a professional music career, he said, "Music is my back-up plan if acting fails."

Watch this video. It's the 'piano concert' from the three disc version. And he's really playing the piano in this video.

He's really, really good. :)

i think he is really playing it cause Robert Pattinson plays the piano

No he wasn't faking it, he was really playing the piano.

I'm pretty sure I heard he DID actually play it. And on one of the DVD's there is 'Edward's Piano Concert' in which you can see Rob playing. link

I think Robert Pattinson was cheating because of how there is no music and he probably doesnt play piano but if he does i dont know.

no he plays in real life

No. Robert Pattinson does play the piano.

He was playing it

I Think They Recorded Him Playing It Then had him fake play it for the Scene Of The movie

He started to play piano when he was about two years old. I have read that somewhere. And he did play piano in the movie.

he was really playing it!

he plays the piano totally sure. in this pic he's practicing =), behind scenes.

i think he is not faking there.i think he is really the one who's playing the piano.

of course and they were in the extras Robert pattenson is a really good musision and if u really watched the extras u would know that

Rob plays piano, guitar, etc. What really happened was that he was practicing for it and played Carter Burwell's version. He said it was pretty easy though.
While they were acting that scene, Rob actually did play the piano and did play that exact song, but what happened then (what might confuse some people) is that then, when all the editing parts and all those things they do after the filming, they put the music "up", I mean, while they were putting all the background music, they also put the Bella's Lullaby one over the scene.

In other words, Rob played it in the real life, but in the editing part the overput Carter Burwell's part ;)