Don't You Think Newborns (like Bree Turner) deserves another chance?

I think she should because she did not want any part in the fight, she didn't want to fight them...so I think she deserved another chance

i think she deserved another chance she surrendered and she was confused she didn't want to be a vampire she had no choice i think jane should have let her lived

Yes, I believe she deserved another chance! Imagine being her, so young, scared, and alone. She looked to me as if she was one of the kids who is not quite ready to have to much place between her and her mommy! (not said sarcasticly). Stupid Jane!

yes becuz she didnt choose that for herself and she wanted to be good and she didnt even try to fight the cullens.

I do believe that Bree Tanner deserved a chance.She just looked...lost.If you know what I mean.Like she was just trying to follow the rest so she wouldn't die.And confused and scared.Poor Bree:(

Yes I do think that newborns should have a chance if they surender because with the help of the right vampires, like the cullens they wouldn't even be a threat any more if they changed their ways and became "vegitairian"

Yes because she didn't do anything wrong. Never drank blood, or fought with the wolves/Cullens.

yes! she probally would have but the volturi new that she knew there little secret! grrrrrrrr i hate them!!

yes i do think she deserves another chance cause she just dosen't no what to do so............... giver her another chance

Yes, of course, none of them didn't knew what they were doing...and it's Tanner

Bree and Deigo do but not Riley or any of the others

yes they do. most of the time its not their fault that they get changed or feed.

She didn't cause any harm-- I don't see why they punished her. Why give a second chance when all she'd done was nothing (well except for the people she killed, but all vamps do that)....They should've let the Cullens keep her.

yes because she really didnt do anything or even fight with the Cullens and the werewolfs so i think she should got another chance

For Bree Tanner yes because she didn't know what was happening. All she knew was she was supposed to destroy the Cullen Clan. The other newborns however, did not deserve a second chance because they actually fought the Cullens and werewolves and they really wanted to destroy the Cullen Clan.

Yes. Her death was just to show the ruthlessness of the Volturi.