Twilight Series

answer this question

Twilight Series Question

How do you feel about this scene in new moon?

How do you feel about the possibility or the fact (however you want to take it) that they are replacing the original scene where bella hops into the motorcycle of a "bad guy" rather than bella just walking down to one eyed petes on foot and seeing edward's vision for the first time? do you think it is fair, or is it too extreme? idk i want to know what you think, because i feel sorta sketchy about it.
How do you feel about this scene in new moon?
 sinai114 posted over a year ago
next question »

Twilight Series Answers

Yoss said:
I think it would be more suspenseful to watch rather than watch Bella trying to making up her mind to go over to the "guys" or not.

We also have to think of the people who haven't read the book who would watch the movie. Our breaths were hitched in that particular scene because we get to read Bella's actual thoughts and that made us drawn into the danger she is attempting and well, Bella or Kristen couldn't really narrate during the entire scene during the movie.

In movies, a certain scene has to depict a lot of things/emotions which would be different in the book were the author could decribe and elaborate. That picture showed (perfectly) Bella throwing caution to the wind,the lure of danger - all just to Edward's voice inside her head.

**I just hope we get to hear Edward/Rob growling in the movie.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I can`t agree wit you more! it has to be easy for the non Twlighters to understand it. I think it would be more influential if the byke scene`s in there.Oh and it looks like we are actually going to see Edward, not only hear his voice!!!
kat_hale posted over a year ago
Lozziebabe666 said:
i dont get it???
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yea cuz ive been hearing these suppperrr weird rumors, and some important blogs, that they might change that scene where bella gets out of the movie theater and approaches "one eyed pete" and then the voice in her head actually says something, and no this picture is actually like right across from one eyed petes, edward is there, cz we know shell see him as a vision instead of hearing his voice, but she isnt just walking to the dangerous guys, i think she actually hops a bike and like goes on a ride with him. I saw the video and they were filming and everything thats why im like really confused because what i know from reading the book, bella doesn't go on anyones bike specially at night by the theater. soooo yea they will most likely change it.
sinai114 posted over a year ago
dusica426 said:
What?! Well if they made it that way then it's stupid. In the book she saw that they were not dangerous and she lost interest in them! Maybe that's a picture of Kirsten and not Bella...
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
NAtii8 said:
i totaly agree with Yoss (comment above)

i think they will prob. change a few things from the book to make it more suspenseful and interesting for those - people that havn't read new moon.

i just hope they don't change too much of the book, it is one of my favs:(
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!