who agrees that robbert should not play edward!! Poll Results - Twilight Guys

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Twilight Guys Who Agrees That Robbert Should Not Play Edward!!

415 fans picked:

67%

yes

19%

.....

15%

twilightgrl123 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

75 comments

twilightgrl123 picked yes:

he ugly!!!!!

posted over a year ago.

gileygirl picked no:

i am already over it. he's fine, and he will do just fine and thats why they casted him for the part, if they didnt think he would do a good job they wouldnt have casted him to play edward. I think he will do okay *shrug*

posted over a year ago.

CharmedAngel88 picked no:

I think he's perfect!

posted over a year ago.

cowgirlfromhell picked no:

He wouldn't have been casted if he isn't going to do a good job or if he's ugly. He's going to do a good job and he's alright looking. It's Taylor who's been cast as Jacob who I have a problem with, Steven Strait will always be Jake in my mind.

posted over a year ago.

TheBetafish picked no:

I think he's perfectly fine. And I agree, because Jacob, on the other hand should have been Steven Strait.

posted over a year ago.

Lunatic picked no:

He'll be great.

posted over a year ago.

CullenCult picked no:

Lunatic is rite.. he'll do fine

posted over a year ago.

ellolove77 picked yes:

He doesn't look like how she describes him in the book.

posted over a year ago.

forgetmenot1234 picked yes:

edward should be hott and that guy is BUTT UGLY!!!! I see edward as looking like chace crawford cause chace crawford is HOTT!!!!!!

posted over a year ago.

ShinyLicious20 picked no:

No, He isn't ugly, i think Robert look so freak hot to me because He looks - good in Edward ,NO MATTER WHAT if does he can fit in edward,stupidfan who does don't like him IN edward then YOU DON'T NEED TO WATCH MOVIE. I knew it Robert will be great! i was glad he got part.

posted over a year ago.

vickiee_93 picked yes:

I think he'll do great either way the Edward is not gonna look the way we want him to do, we all pictured him differently. So I think he'll do great.

posted over a year ago.

screw_love_5116 picked no:

at first when i found out that he was playing edward i FREAKED!! but i decided he is not that bad (i only thought that is because he was cedric in hp)

posted over a year ago.

.....

day-z1995 picked .....:

i didnt at first but then i saw him with kirstin or wot eva her name is (de grl hu plays bella) nd i fink its actually right den playin dem parts 2geva ..:D

posted over a year ago.

Edward901 picked yes:

NOOOOOOOOOOO

posted over a year ago.

alicecullen97 picked no:

I AM A HUGE ROBERT SUPPORTER!!!!!
I LOVE HIM!

posted over a year ago.

sarinha picked yes:

i think he is exactly wat edward was suppost to look like... rob is soo hot, wen i first found out he looked weird but he kinda grew on me... i think he is perfect... kristen him and th rest of the cast are great!! cant wait till it comes out ... ( and the book too :) )

posted over a year ago.

Impulse85 picked no:

Leave the dude alone, he'll be fine, there's nothing wrong with him. Not everyone may agree with the choice, but you know what, they'll live and get over it. The world isn't going to end or stop spinning because you don't like Robert. Get over it. The people in Hollywood are not going to change the cast just because of a few cry babies.

posted over a year ago.

last edited over a year ago

.....

oo_jason- picked .....:

i think you should make your answers to your questions longer. not just yes and no and ....

posted over a year ago.

MrsOShea92825 picked yes:

I don't like him because 1. he's ugly and 2. he's from Harry Potter and i don't think that they should mix the 2 because in the book world they are competitors sort of. i know that must sound stupid, but it makes sense in my mind.

posted over a year ago.

Eclipse picked no:

He is HOTTT!!!

posted over a year ago.

isabell118 picked no:

At first i wasn't to sure about him as Edward but then I saw him with Bella/Kristen and they look perfect together!

posted over a year ago.

Edward901 picked yes:

i've gotten used to looking at his face, i still don't like him being edward, but i accept it

posted over a year ago.

twilightgrl123 picked yes:

ok ive accepted it and robbert is actualt pretty cute just not my ideal edward but im fine with it and i think he'll do fine!

posted over a year ago.

.....

BritKeyser picked .....:

I think he's Ok, but he wasn't what I had in mind, course, I don't think you could get to what me or anyone else had in mind.

posted over a year ago.

.....

brucas4ever picked .....:

i totally agree with gileygirl

posted over a year ago.

kayem91 picked no:

I watched the 4th harry potter movie and I saw him then I read Twilight and I said that robert was perfect for edward

posted over a year ago.

fununderthesun picked yes:

Hayden Cristensen would be perfect. or even jackson Rathbone(idk if thats how u spell it) would be good

posted over a year ago.

booklover picked no:

i think robert is a good enough actor for edward...i mean who else could play him???

posted over a year ago.

.....

MrsECullen picked .....:

Im not sure.. but i think that is as close as we are ever gonna get. I mean, i know she describes him really well, but we all have different opinions of what he should look like, so they can never get it exactly right can they? Also, Stephenie seems to be very happy with the choice. Plus, he is pretty hot! &&& Hes English!! *swwoooonnnnssss* xxx

posted over a year ago.

Aryn picked no:

he's cool. and from the clips I've seen from the movie, he's done a good job.

posted over a year ago.

Aryn picked no:

and the answers, i think, are confusing some ppl. what is yes and what is no?

posted over a year ago.

clburkes picked yes:

he can't do it................. Dear god i hope he can

posted over a year ago.

kaylee3 picked no:

he will be great for the part, that's why he was picked. DUH! & on top of all that he is hot.

posted over a year ago.

.....

I_luv_nessie picked .....:

He's cute and i think he will be good cant really say how good until i see the movie

posted over a year ago.

tatay picked no:

He's alright. But I think he'll be good for this part. Personally, I don't think he's that cute.

posted over a year ago.

Conner95 picked no:

most people think i am crazy but i think he will be awsome at this part and i dont care what people think i loved him as cedgric diggory

posted over a year ago.

midnightsun123 picked no:

i totally agree with any1 who says hes gonna be great!!!!! hes reli good looking in harry potter and to be fair every1 has a different version of edward in their minds so nobody will be perfect

posted over a year ago.

MrsCullen1918 picked no:

he's hot but not exactly edward

posted over a year ago.

SexyNo8 picked no:

yeh i agree. i can see wot ur saying and i agree in a way that yh there are so many guys out there and they choose robert pattison but when you hear him talk and look at bella it's exactly how you would imagine it.... perfect! (i found the best song for them! Spiralling by Keane!)

posted over a year ago.

BeSafe picked no:

Okay so no I don't agree that Robert Pattinson shouldn't play Edward...I mean he isn't who I pictured, but he is kind of perfect for the part...:)

posted over a year ago.

Edwards_Bella picked no:

i am a HUGE Robert Supporter! He is perfect 4 edward i think! He's going to be and is perfect and great 4 edward! I just see him as edward BUT THIS IS an opinion

posted over a year ago.

BrucasChair picked no:

^
totally!!! :)
he's gonna do great, and if u don't like him, then just don't go watch the movie, solution made..

posted over a year ago.

xtwilightluvax picked no:

No! I think he's perfect for Edward. He'll be great. If u complain then stuff it. Us Robbert fans love him n if u don't then thats fine you're opinion- not mine just don't expect to watch the movie and not see him.

posted over a year ago.

house1 picked no:

did u even see twilight???

did u see how HOT HE WAS AND NOT ONLY THAT HE DID THE BEST ACTING!!!!

posted over a year ago.

TwilightSonya picked yes:

He doesnt realy fit into the character

posted over a year ago.

nevermind606 picked no:

I thought he was great. :D

posted over a year ago.

tooch picked no:

He was absoloutely fantastic!!
And Robert being from England and all, he did the American accent really well.
He was the BEST Edward Cullen.

-xo.

posted over a year ago.

last edited over a year ago

odd-duck picked no:

He was perfect for it! and after the way he was treated by so some called fans, i think he's great!

posted over a year ago.

laley_lover picked no:

i could imagine anyone else
he did it so well
he is perfect as Edward

posted over a year ago.

edward_4_ever picked no:

Robert Pattinson Did amazing and if you don't like him playing Edward then don't go see the movie duh! Problem solved.

posted over a year ago.

itailianjr120 picked no:

he was great edward!

posted over a year ago.

.....

Twilightluver78 picked .....:

At first when I saw him in the trailers, OME he looked so hot but then when i saw him out of work uh yea ppl can guess wat happened
lol
OCD>>>>>Obsessive Cullen Disorder<<<<<<
lol
<3 Edward Cullen Luver

posted over a year ago.

TEAM-EDWARDxxx picked no:

Whoeva thinks that Robbert Pattison is ugly.... SHOULD GET SUM GLASSES.. he's bloody HOTT!!! 'gosh' leave him alone he did a great job acting as edward cullen and it will stay like that... if u think he's ugly then dnt watch the bloody movie.... he's a great actor and hes AWSUM!!! and nobodys perfect...... what if u were in a movie and sum one was bagging out how ugly u were u wouldnt like that..... so just bak off!!!

posted over a year ago.

last edited over a year ago

NessNess picked no:

Well...maybe if you spelled his name right...

posted over a year ago.

Twilight4life22 picked no:

Okay.For those of you who say he is wrong because he is not what you saw in your head, DUH. We all saw someone different and how in the hell could they cast someone to fit in with EVERYONE'S vision? He does an amazing job and I think he will win over those who don't like him. PLUS, how is he supposed to live up to the descrition in the book. I thinkno one could live up to that. Robert Pattinson is great. He is very very good looking but, I like his singing too. Any one else feel the same?

posted over a year ago.

ParanormalxTAPS picked yes:

that guy looks like a butt.

posted over a year ago.

Ashley_Ari picked no:

he's the best ever.....he did the best playing edward...

posted over a year ago.

ivabella picked no:

he's adorable!

posted over a year ago.

.....

iLoVeObAmA picked .....:

..................

posted over a year ago.

monkey97sta picked no:

OMG how could you put that question???? I love Robert Pattinson and he is the perfect Edward!! I love you Robert Pattinson! And if you think that he is a bad Edward you shouldn't be posting bad things on a Edward Fansite!!!

posted over a year ago.

last edited over a year ago

brittanybalcom picked no:

he rocks man
hot

posted over a year ago.

wolfgirl4life picked no:

he dosnt look like the discription in the book at all

posted over a year ago.

bobbie4chris picked yes:

i'm sorry but edward is ment 2 dazzle every1 but he does not dazzle me !

posted over a year ago.

livrox picked yes:

No offence to all the Robert Pattinson lovers out there but I really hate him, he's a TERRIBLE actor. There are so many people that could have done a better job than he did.

posted over a year ago.