Yeah, this is a tough one... But I kind of have to go with Eva. Chef is scary and all, but Eva pulled a bus with her teeth and fought off Sasquatchenakwa! Even Chef is scared of Sasquatchenakwa, as shown in "Camp Castaways."

Alright. As much as Eva kicks serious ass, i'm gonna give this one to Chef.
He HAS had military training, has he not? >v>"
And CHECK OUT the muscles on that man! >:U

But i hate chosing between men and women in physical fights. Because i'm not sure if a man would be comfortable fighting a woman, and i hate to sound sexsist even though i'm not. You guys understand what i mean, right? Dx

^ I understand, and I don't think you're sexist for picking Chef. It'd only be sexist if you picked Chef and said "Of course he'd win he's a man, isn't he?" :)

SHE PULLED A TRUCK WITH HER TEETH
SHE HAS MUSCELS

although i hate her...