I would chose darcy because she is the smartest . Icy is more cruel

For me it'd be Icy or Darcy, I think they are both very smart. But Icy is more cunning and ruthless. When she has a goal she doesn't give up on it, she's the one that keeps the trix moving. I also think she is the most powerful and evil of the three. The reason I would not say Stormy is because she has the shortest temper and is the most immature.

^ I agree; Stormy relies more on her anger and attitude to frighten and get things accomplished, which really isn't a way to do things. Anger and jealously can make you sloppy in your work and your attitude can only get you so far. (I'd be surprised if a meticulous villain lasted long on those traits a lone) Darcy I find, is manipulative but I find that she does tend to put her feelings before the actual task. (Like with Riven and Valtor) Though she does turn on them eventually—or use them in the process, she still cares for them slightly which isn't good. Villains really shouldn't feel true compassion towards something; it makes them give off a weaker and softer aura, which I know none of the Trix want.

Icy is and always will be the best leader for them in my opinion. She's a sociopath, narcissist, above-average intelligence and calculated. She doesn't act irrationally and usually thinks her plans over. (Like trying to steal the Dragon Fire, she planned what the three of them we're going to do. She didn't just jump into the scenario; that would have been a complete failure and disaster on their part) She tends to not care for anyone but herself, and her sisters. She ends up using the main bad-guys, or getting her revenge viciously after having enough of them. Like Zannie says, she never gives up, which is something all leaders should show off. She exudes power. I mean, if you could take over Cloudtower, give life to a diseased army and then destroy two other schools—without giving a fuck about the consequences or who would try and stop you—should show how ruthless she is. (Which is why I don't like the way she's been portrayed in season 5. They're making her seem weak and lovesick...which isn't Icy at all :P)

^ Well put. And I totally agree I hate the direction they are taking their characters in season 5. It is so disappointing. Icy is a love sick wimp in season 5 and the trix always lose. Worse than in the other seasons. I hate it so much. I also hate how they are making Darcy and Stormy almost go against Icy. Over all season 5 sucks and the trix aren't even the trix anymore. I think I'll stick to rewaching seasons 1-3.

^ I also agree. I liked the Trix more in Season 1 and Season 2 since they were cruel and had a cold heart. Now in Season 5, Icy is acting all so lovey-dovey and sweet with Tritannus like she's some kind of helpless girly-girl. What happened to the old Trix that we knew?! What is Season 5 doing with our witches?!

^Agreed!! Icy because she has the mean-cruel personality of a great witch. Stormy is short-tempered and Darcy's the nice witch and would spoil it. But I could not believe how Icy became, so..so girly !!!!

xD right! Look at all of us agreeing people!

they would be lost without icy

Icy! For her hatred to Bloom! XD

^^ Indeed

Darcy and Stormy don't need more attention.

I feel like they kind of do...all the Trix do honestly.

Darcy would also make a good leader.Stormy not so much.

^