I wanna see his interactions with pam...and keep the michael hatred alive...but i guess we can see the chemistry btw michael and the new hr

I'll be honest, I like Toby but the only reason I want him to come back is because of how much Michael hates him.

He's just so adorable.

the premiere should be called "Hello Toby."

I haven't given her a chance yet but I'm not a huge Holly fan. I guess I don't like change, I'm old and set in my ways and I'm looking for my third chair.

i bet he'll be back for an episode and will like confess his undying love for pam

I liked him until he started being a creeper at the end of season 4.

i agree with tessajanuary. I'm just starting to notice how big of a creeper he really is. the only thing i like about him are the Michael/Toby interactions. those are priceless, really.

i hated toby soooooo much. the first few seasons he was tolerable but once he started interfering with jim and pam, i was ready for him to go.

I liked Toby, but now that he's gone I'm kind of over it. I loved that Michael hated him so much, but now I find his interactions with Holly funny so I don't really care that Toby's gone.