I liked Jared better at first even though he did hit Wanda, but as I continued reading I fell more and more in love with Ian.

I thought I was supposed to like Jared more.. But then I loved Ian.
I was mad because I knew that Ian was falling in love with Wanda, and I thought it wasn't fair to him. I almost cried because I'd convince myself that Ian was not going to be happy in the end (I don't know why, I just did)

But I was wrong!!! I was SSOO happy that Ian was with Wanda in the end, because he loves her.
[[I'm sorry for the rant, but it's true]]

I like Kyle a lot because of how sweet he is to Sunny. I also like Ian, and way more than Kyle, but I added Kyle, so I decided to vote for him. I think Kyle is a good guy, or at least an honest one, besides the trying to kill Wanda part. Ian is really sweet, and he seems to have a good connection to Wanda's brain, meaning that he thinks about how she would feel in specific situations before he puts her through them.

aww, kyle. it's so nice that someone added him. i definitely like him more than i like jared, but ian is my favorite by far.

I honestly, truly, love them both. Stephenie makes all her characters believable and real. Jared doesn't really love Wanda, I don't think (his lies at the end confused me a little) but he would end up loving her eventually. And Ian definetly loves Wanda for who she is, and probably in any body, too. But before Mel was taken, Jared looked after her like he had known her for his whole life, not just a month. He also looked after Jamie whereas I think Ian just took more notice of Jamie when he found out that Wanda loved Jamie.

I can't decide between Ian and Jared I like really fell in love with them!!! Kyle would be either second or third!!! I liked Kyle but definitely not as much as Ian or Jared!!! This is sooo hard!!=)

I don't really like Ian because I identified more with Melanie so I ended up liking Jared most!

haha.. Ian or Jared? KYLE!!
yeah, not one of the two answers.
Anyways, I found that amusing. :)

awww Ian i love him so much he is really the greatest! =D

I liked Jared at first, the Jared from Mel's memories, but once Ian started being nice to Wanda...well he's the best <333
I was so mad when she going to give Mel her body back and wanted to be burried, I was all D=< NOOOO What about Ian?!!!...T_T...but it's all good ^^

i actually do think ian is better than kyle, but not enough people like kyle and i love him to death so i had to vote for him. minus that whole "must kill wanda" bit, he totally rocks.

but not as much as ian, of course. ^_^

I've answered this question 10 times, and it's always Ian. He just gets to me. & I always refer to the quote at the end of the book that stole my heart: "I held you in my hand, Wanderer. And you were so beautiful." How can you not fall for a guy ilke that?

I've said it like 10 times IAN FTW!! He kicks ass! Jared is awesome too just not as awesome!

omg who put in kyle?!?!? no that is not even funny, not cool. kyle is such a butt, he's only good when sunny comes.

Jared was too old, in my opinion, and he was a abusive man. Ian was perfect for her. He liked her for her personality and not what she looked like.

Both!! :)

Ian

OMG IAN OF COURSE! I really fell in love with him, i love his character! <3 Ian

i <3 Ian

yeah...Jared was a BIG disappointment!

jared was cooler.

I definitely think it is Ian who at first made a bad impression but later on I started liking Ian who seemed much kinder. Like Wanda said he was kind as a soul. Jared was a big idiot. Always not trusting until the end. He was blah. I don't want to read about him if there was a sequel I rather read about Kyle.

Can i have them BOTH!!!!

love him so much!

he is soooo adoriable

Kyle reminds me so much of my lil cousin who I love but my I absolutely LOVE Ian so yeah.