Now that i think about it I think Missy peregrym would do a good job playing Wanda/melanie. She kinda fits my idea of what i think of both of them.I think she would have played the role of Bella much better than Kristen Stewart!!

either megan fox or sophia bush

I would LOVE for Sophia to play Melanie!

For some reason the Melanie in my mind's eye was always Sophia Bush. Even before I went online and found a gazillion videos/manips with her as Mel :)

i think Jensen Ackles as Jared, and Katie Cassidy as Melanie, would be PERFECT !
(:

well to be honest i think my close friends deserves this role... as Jamie... his name Ivan Hoey. he has auditioned for the role of Seth Clearwater and failed... but he is not going to let this stop him as he told me... and as well he looks like the description of Jamie with the exception of hair and eye color other then that he is great... please visit his website at www.ivanhoey.webs.com and tell me what you think

I think Odette Yustman looks exactly like the description of Melanie.She's the best Melanie ever!

the idea of megan fox as melanie/wanda makes me wanttoo throw up, please please don't do that to us, i don't think i can see it if that is the case, a good story deserves a good cast to portray it, not talentless bimbos aka M.F

Sophia <3

Sophia Bush. <3

While reading the book, I always pictured younger, Buffy-style Eliza Dushku, but she is a little too old to play Melanie now. I think Camilla Belle, Odette Yustman, or Summer Glau could really pull it off. They fit her description the best and have been in certain movies and played certain characters that would help them portray Melanie.

i think sophia bush is the best but i also like megan fox to be melanie

I would love love love Hannah Taylor Gordon to be Melanie!

When I first read the description I instantly pictured her as Camilla Belle! Olivia Wilde might also be a good Melanie too, but not as good as Camilla Belle!

Odette :)