After S4 everything went downhill for oTH

One episode of OTH was more than enough.

Gossip Girl is getting better whereas One Tree Hill is getting worse and worse.

GG became awful since season 2 , while OTH only after main characters finished school (season 4)

never watch one tree hill....

I actually love the later seasons of One Tree Hill. Jamie is adorable and I love that Lucas and Peyton (eventually) got a happy ending.

I like both shows, but OTH is better ;)

In the high school years OTH pwns GG in every single way.

Always!! My favourite TV show!

GG totally PWNS One Tree Hill!!!

I only liked OTH when it was about when they were in high school.

I've tried watching Gossip Girl since Michelle Trachtenberg has been on it-- and I've got to support my Buffy the Vampire Slayer actors. But I found the show so boring-- I really can't watch it. I wasn't really crazy about any of the characters-- my favorite was probably Dorota. And I don't think I liked any of the couples very much. But mostly I just couldn't get into any of the story lines...
My roommate watched it so I ended up seeing the first 2 1/2 seasons, but I haven't watched since half way through season 3... so in all fairness- maybe the show got better.

One Tree Hill is one of my favorite shows. I think the first 3 seasons are by far the best... but the only season I was really disappointed with was season 6-- which still had some great story lines and a lot of great moments. I think OTH on it's worst day is better than GG on it's best day (at least from the first 2 1/2 seasons of GG since that's all I really saw).

Only seasons 1-6 though are better than GG

I love both shows but eventually I like GG more. But both shows have amazing characters and great couples. Storylines are usually interesting but of course there are always some that I don't like at all. What makes me love GG more is probably the setting, the fashion and the whole atmosphere in general. It's just a bit more captivating.

^^ I agree that GG has a great setting and great fashion. But I guess I'm biased cause they film right near where I live <3

A lot of my friends have been extras on the show... and they film pretty frequently in one of my favorite areas of Central Park--- so that makes the show cool in my opinion. But it's not enough to make me want to watch it.

I've quit oth after s6

I find the cast of Gossip Girl are way more attractive. So it makes me wanna watch the show more. And there are something about the storyline that is really addictive .
OTH. I only and only likes Brooke.

Love GG too,
But OTH is my all-time favorite show!

GG by far <3

both.

Both!