I think being the young lover that he is, he'd be a little awkward, but a good kisser. Sweeney (who I'd love to be kissed by) probably hasn't kissed since his Lucy. Turpin's freaking creepy, Toby's a kid, Pirelli- I don't know about him.

Sweeney-too depressed

Beadle-too disgusting

Turpin-too old

Toby-no experience

Pirelli-awful mustache that would probably get in the way

So, Anthony it is.

Turpin. Probably has the most experience.

My name's Lucy! =D

After reading the comments, I am not too certain about my own pick anymore...

Anyway, I had to laugh at the Pirelli part from KateKicksAss's comment. ;D

Sweeney todd Forever!!

I would want to kiss Sweeney the most but Anothony is kinder and more gentle and sweet and not all depressed soooo...

Him, Anthony, or Sweeney, for sure...

I can think of all kinds of things I'd let Pirelli do to me with those lips and that stache.Most of them aren't suitable to post here.

sweeney! :)