Click the picture for the full view ;)

I love this one. It features our favorite angel!

I actually think the S5 one kinda sucks. :( What's with the glowy/shadowy people? They look like aliens or something. Or at least that's what it makes me think of...more of a scifi vibe.

^ I agree! I get the whole 'Lucifer rises from a hole, Sam & Adam falling into the hole' representative but it kind of sucks still. :P

Yeah...I get what they were trying to go for, but meh. They could've done so much better. I've loved every cover up until S5. :(

just the whole hand coming out of the ground is what made this choice easy, it signified that our favorite big brother was coming back lol :D

I agree fanfly .. but maybe it won't be as bad as it looks in person/on the actual DVD. Hopefully. xD

i like both, but sam looks slightly hotter in this one, soo... :P

^Exactly. :)

But why don't they have Cas in the S5 cover???

@shomill ; Cause' he's just a "guest~star". He's not a main character like Sam & Dean. Although he's in a lot of episodes, and he's very well liked .. technically the show is still about Sam & Dean. I guess they wanted that represented on the cover.

Last season was a bit different because it was his first season and everyone LOVED him when he was introduced. ♥

Both, I couldn't really choose. Buttt I dig this one I suppose. :)