I think it would be Knuckles because Tails and Amy would be too upset about Sonic's...death *cries hysterically* to do anything. Shadow would probably just continue fighting on his own, and the rest would follow Knux's orders

i think shadow because shadow and sonic are like the exact same!so it would be like replcing sonic with a moodier,grumpier,and more angry sonic!

shadows intelligent cool and is great to lead

Ok Whos The Idiot Who Thinks Cream The Rabbit Is Nothing? I LOVE CREA THE RABBIT WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO ABOUT IT. HUH?

come on!! why not tails? he is sonic buddy!!

Tails is sonics buddy good point Sonicrules

Sonicwave96 it was a joke get it nothing aginst Cream i like her too.
Ok Ok

All Right Shadow0916 But I Got An Eye On You, Decides I Think I Was Overeacting A Little

Oh And Tails´Idea For This Pick Is Not Bad At All

it was about time you
Shadow0916, showed some respect to cream and i am not kidding i like cream and i mean like, like, love, love,

come on why not chris he's the frist non evil human Sonic ever met.

(Update silver and blaze added)

Tails is just a kid and knux shadow and the guys wont take orders from a little girl like amy will they and i think shadow cos he is a natural born leader.

and sonicwave96 is right cream has done a load to carry the team and she is very cool and we all should pay sum respect towards her

I`m sick of everone picking shadow !!!

i know this is extremly wrong but whatever. Fox power!

If I died, I would pick mah best friend!

Tails is already the Captain on the plane, why not lead EVERYONE?

tails is leader in sonic chronicals, but sonic does the work

WHO THE HECK WOULD ADD VECTOR, ESPIO. AND CHARMY????
THY SUCK MAN!!!

mnsc12 You suck!

dude mnsc12! that was mean to say! i love espio and charmy and vector! HOW COULD YOU SAY SOMETHING LIKE THAT AND NOT THINK ABOUT OTHERS FEELINGS?! (i sound like a little kid saying that. XP)

I think tails deserves to be the leader because he's Sonic's best friend and sidekick