Do you like the actor they chose for Lupin or do you think Faramir {from LOTR} would be a better fit? Or do you have another suggestion?

I love the guy that they chose for Remus. He did and is doing at this point, a wonderful job. He brings that emotion that I find in Remus to the from and he captivates me. No, I cannot say his acting as Remus is like Heath Ledger in The Dark Knight but who's will ever match that. So my vote is that David Thewlis is my Remus Lupin.

I think that the person chosen has played the part very well, and i don't think anyone would play lupin the way he did

I actually really like the gut they chose for Lupin ^^

The guy who played Faramir would have done an okay job as well, but I don't think he is a spitting image of the character or anything.

I didn't really like the actor they chose for Remus - but I can't very well explain why. I was watching Return of the King the other day, and found myself thinking that Remus and Faramir were a little bit similar - just sort of unassumingly cool characters. This led, eventually, to the thought that perhaps Faramir's actor would have been a better choice for the role of Remus. So... yes, that is my vote.

David Thewlis had applied originally for the role of Quirrell in Harry Potter & the Philosopher's Stone ... But Chris Columbus has not accepted. Alfonso Cuaron has thought about him for the role of Lupin ... That's how it turned out there! ^ ^ But I love this actor (though not my favorite among favorite ^ ^)

My private idea of Lupin was quite different, influenced by a picture on the book, but now I think no-one could be better then David Thewlis :)

David Thewlis was the perfect chocie for lupin because he is the best actor ever and i love lupin :)

I thought David Thewlis was great at playing Remus Lupin but maybe Jamie Bell would've been a better fit because he's younger and I could see him fit into the role. David Thewlis still did a great job :) xx