Do you think Hikaru should be with Haruhi? Or should it really be Tamaki with her?

Well as much as I think they would be a cute couple, Haruhi would be better off with Tamaki. Hikaru is too needy for Haruhi, who has only given and worked her whole life. Tamaki would love her in a way where he would let her do her own thing, but say no when he thinks she is over working herself.
EX) He lets Haruhi decide many things for herself, but when push comes to shove like when they were at the beach, he will put his foot down.
He is also more understanding compared to Hikaru. Plus I have a feeling that if Hikaru gets together with Haruhi, the crack in Hikaru and Kaoru's relationship will grow.

i really think that tamakixharuhi would be a lot better tamaki as was already said lets her do her own thing but if he needs to he does something and they just look better together but thats me a lot of people disagree with my shipings like a lot of people think it's stupid that i love ciel x sebastian (link) and hikaru is as said already to needy for haruhi

I personally like her better with Tamaki. :D

i like Haruhi be with tamaki are a beautiful couple that would i believe:)

I think they should but break up. I do love the twins but with that Hikaru would learn that Haruhi is not the one but they still remand friends and the twins still stay together. Then Haruhi finds out later that what see wass looking for all along was Tamaki.

I think Tamaki and Haruhi make a cuter couple,
I just think that because Hikaru is sort of using Haruhi as a step into reality but her and Tamaki have a more romantic feeling than that

Nope <//3 none of them <//3

KYOUYAXHARUHI FOREVER <3333

I think Haruhi doesn't even deserve Hikaru.He's too good for her.And besides,who doesn't like a bit of brotherly love? XD

Hikaru and Haruhi. I love Kaoru and Hikaru and I think him and Haruhi are cute together.

well i think Hikaru and Haruhi are a cute couple but now i think that Tamaki and Haruhi are a much better couple then Hikaru and Haruhi.

hikaru and haruhi are just so cute and good for each other i wish them love and happniess!LoL
if you do leave a comment below

Haruhi and Hikaru makes a cute couple for me because I like the way Hikaru is being jelous because of Haruhi but I think Haruhi and Tamaki makes a much cuter couple because it is simply that i think Tamaki is the best match for Haruhi.. ♥♥

I hate splitting up twins, so I have to go with Tamaki.

tamaki/!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ^_^

I think she and Tamaki makes a more interesting and cute couple. I love Tamaki and HIkaru, but if I had to choose which one should be with Haurhi, definitely Tamaki! ^o^

I like Hikaru and Haruhi more,but because of how much I like Hikaru I have to say Haruhi and Tamaki..

I ship Tamaki with Haruhi. I don't currently ship Hikaru with anyone, though.

I personally think Tamaki deserves to be with Haruhi better. He's had more experience with her in the relationships part (i.e. spending more time together) and he seems very entitled to her in a sweet way, even though he's not aware of his feelings all the time.

However, I find Tama-chan extremely annoying and irritating.     SneakyFox48 said that he lets her do what she wants to, but puts his foot down when it's enough - that's sort of true, but sort of incorrect. I feel Tamaki doesn't really give Haruhi room to grow toward the world, you know what I mean? He kind of keeps her for himself in a way.

But, so does Hikaru. He's adorable and cute, and I really really ship HikaHaru (or whatever the ship name is ;) ) but I find it really annoying that he doesn't pay as much attention to her as Tamaki and doesn't get fiery when Tamaki hits on Haruhi (which I think is cliché but at the same time more dramatizing). He rarely shows his feelings, except for that date-purposefully-set-up-by-Kaoru thunderstorm moment. huehue

Overall I much prefer HikaHaru but I see how TamaHaru makes more sense.