He has Haley.

he has Peyton!!!

lucas as had both brooke and peyton who are both amazing people but i think over all nathan is better hes had someone who has commited with him and has been with him no matter what there has been no love triangles or anything and haley is amazing in every aspect

when you say lucky, do you mean the luck hes had with girls or do you mean who gorgeous his girls have been? haha cause if its the first one then nathan and the second one then lucas. but im going with the first definition and nathan is super lucky to have haley who loves him so much :]

he had 2 best friends fighting over him wat couldnt be luckier

nathan had peyton and brooke now he has haley who LOVES him and gave him jamie.....he has it all!!!

he's definitely oth's biggest heartbreaker.

Nathan has been with just about every girl, but he stayed with the best one :]
Totally agree with livelovelaugh, because she IS amazing in every aspect and completely commited to him, and he is in love, I mean TRUE love, which Lucas tends to barely ever have... Always switching who he "loves".
And, I have to disagree with you kuhrissten, I think that Haley is gorgeous.

well if you think about it Nathan and Luke had both Brooke and Peyton the only one Nathan has that Luke doesn't is Haley...but Luke is a huge heart breaker as abs said!!all the girls fell for him:)he has his way!!!

I think we're mixing up True love with figuring out your heart. Luke tends to run from his feelings, but it doesn't change that deep down he does have a true love. He just needs to admit it to himself to make up his mind, and go after what he truly wants.

TOTALLY! AND PEYTON HAS HAD THE BEST GUYS! NATHAN,LUKE AND JAKE! <3

BUT BROOKE HAS LUKE,NATE,CHASE,OWEN! HMMM TOUGH ONE!

NAH IT STILL GOES TO PEYTON I LOVE JAKE!

they both have someone who loves them more than anything, so they're both pretty lucky! but naley had had a little less drama than leyton. nathan has a beautiful family, he's so lucky!

someone always wants him and peyton would do ne thin to prove her love <3

ps..he's just lucky cuz he has peyton

Haley James Scott ♥

well i think lucas is the luckiest. nathan's love life doesn't have to do with luck. nathan treats his wife with respect and loves her and puts her first before anything... so he gets love and respect given back in return. with nathan- his love life has nothing to do with luck.

lucas is just lucky. he's lucky that he has had three incredible women fall in love with him after treating them so badly... and then they continue to love him even after he leaves them and continues on with another woman. and then not only have those 3 women continued to love him... but they have all forgave him for his wrong doings. has he done anything to deserve that forgiveness? well, i don't think forgiveness is given because it's deserved-- it's given because it's needed. and lucas is LUCKY enough to have fallen in love with three women compassionate enough to grant him forgiveness. i think it's much more about luck with lucas... and with nathan it's about getting what he deserves.