If a different actress played peyton who would you choose.(other then Hilary Burton, please don't add her) Poll Results - One Tree Hill

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

One Tree Hill If a different actress played peyton who would you choose.(other then Hilary Burton, please don't add her)

105 fans picked:

Kirsten Bell

46%

Mischa Barton

15%

Blake Lively

13%

Hilarie Duff

Haylie Duff

Kristen Cavallari

Keep Hilarie

(added by gossipchic13)

lizisme posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

14 comments

	lizisme picked Mischa Barton: or kristen bell. i would probably like peyton better just because i love mischa posted over a year ago.

	othgirl_peyton picked Kirsten Bell: i love Kristen! but nobody could replace Hilarie she is amazing! posted over a year ago.

	3liiiiin picked Blake Lively: Blake yeah!! I'd love that :D:D posted over a year ago.

	mtoll4 picked Kirsten Bell: Hilarie cant be replaced:p BUT Kristen Bell is AMAZING!! she is so talented and so cool.. She would be awesome :D posted over a year ago.

	fr34kygl picked Kirsten Bell: I'd be sooooo torn between brucas and leyton if she were played by kirsten!! The I would seriously consider leyton being end game :D posted over a year ago.

	Lila856 picked Kirsten Bell: OMG I LOOOOVE KRISTEN!!! plus i always thought veronica & peyton are SO ALIKE! but i`d def rather stick to hil, she is the only peyton! P.S. lizisme hun i think you got your hilarys mixed up . posted over a year ago.

	abs07 picked Mischa Barton: I just started watching the OC and it's not half bad. it's corny, but I think Mischa would play a half good peyton. She already played a tortured character on the OC so it would be a good transition. No one plays peyton better than hilarie though. posted over a year ago.

	1treehillfan said: same answer as the comment i posted on the "if a different actress played brooke" pick posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Angelika picked Haylie Duff: Hilarie for ever lol!!!no one could be a better Peyton than her!! posted over a year ago.

	tvfan5 picked Kirsten Bell: i love kristen but noone can replace hilarie..EVER posted over a year ago.

	doyouknow picked Kirsten Bell: I LOVE LOVE LOVE LOOOOOVE Kirsten Bell. posted over a year ago.

	kathiria82 picked Kirsten Bell: Hilarie is irreplaceable! No one can play Peyton better than her, EVER! posted over a year ago.

	Nine00 picked Kirsten Bell: The Duff's suck posted over a year ago.

	ns_23 picked Kirsten Bell: Not Mischa Barton lol posted over a year ago.