She said she wanted to marry him just not right away and becuase of that he broke up with her and gave up on her when he should have waited becuase he loved her

Lucas is a dickface!

noooo DUH
i seriously love love LOVE nedmcgee!<33
haha :]

Lucas is a moron. "I'll wait for you Lindsey"
WHY DIDNT YOU WAIT FOR PEYTON JACKASS?
(Jackass is such a funny word. I love american words! )

He'll wait for Lidnsay but not Peyton?
Its a bunch of bullshit!
He is such an ass!

Lucas is retarded. he said he would wait for lindsay. but a few years back peyton said to just wait a year and he coulnt do that!!! errr. he annoys me!

^^ lol saul_mikoliunas

OMG,lucas really annoys me!!!

Peyton came back to Tree Hill from LA just for Lucas. And then he was in love with Lindsey. So Lucas gave up, NOT Peyton. Lucas is an BIG asshole in this season!!!

this is what i keep saying to brucasers - well one in particular! *cough* 1treehillfan *cough* - twice its been said now 'lucas is too damn good for peyton.he waited around for her and he jepordized his relationship with brooke twice for her. and she stole lucas from brooke twice and each time she got him, she didnt want him anymore....'

- that is bullshit! seriously you need to watch this series and last series over again! peyton didnt want to leave him - he told her to go to LA so its his fault she left in the first place cause she was gunna stay for him! then when she said SOMEDAY he walked away - she didnt know they were gunna break up! shes said before shell wait forever for him - he should of done that for her!! and about the first bit 'he jepordized his relationship with brooke twice for her' - that is crap - did she not watch s1 either - peyton jepordized her friendship with brooke for him! does she think luke gave a crap about brooke s1 all he wanted was peyton - it was her that didnt want to hurt brooke - not for just a fling! :@ 'she stole lucas from brooke twice'??? did she? cause s3 i dont remember that i must of missed it - peyton waited for brucas to have closure and be over for good - FGS she tried to get them back together on brookes birthday!!! the first time was all 3 of them - brooke knew luke and peyton had something there and she still fell for him - peyton gave in to lucas in the end(thats all she did) - luke was the one that could of told brooke to go when peyton came to his house that night saying shed made a mistake she wants what he wants! cause he obv wanted her then! he should of ended it with brooke sooner than he did - he didnt have to bring peyton down to his level - she would of still been there when he broke up with brooke!!!
ALL LUCAS FAULT FOR EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENEDD!

peyton did when she said someday to lucas

they both gave up on each other. They gave up in different ways, but they both gave up.

hellokitten08, last time I checked, "someday" didn't mean never. Luke's the the one who interpreted it that way. If peyton gave up on luke, she wouldn't have reacted the way she did when he broke up with her and left her in new york without so much as a real goodbye...

for your information, laurra, i said that about season 1, not about season 4 so keep your rude, obnoxious clueless coments to yourself, k?
this is about seaon 4- which is a completely different situation.
to be honest, all peyton really did was refuse his proposal. she was young, and she still loved him but she wasn't ready to get married. but, it only irritated me because she was perfectly willing to marry jake when she was SEVENTEEN. but, all her dreams were coming true for her and she still loved luke she just wasnt ready to settle down- especially with her being so young and just blossoming into the music buisness. :D
luke acted like a big baby and walked away, which was upsetting to me because i like luke and know he can be a better person then that. anyways, mostly it was lukes fault.

LOL Laurra "ALL LUCAS FAULT FOR EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENEDD!" - couldn't have said it better myself ;D

^^she wasn't ready to marry Jake and Jake knew that and was a good guy about it, so he asked her who was really in her heart - again because he is the sweetest most lovely guy! <3

Lucas on the other hand..........clearly wasn't ready for marriage and this time Peyton was the sensible one as Jake had been - and pointed out neither of them where really ready at the moment BUT that she did love him and WANT to be with HIM! (this is the difference between the JP situation Lucas IS Peyton's true love - UNFORTUNATELY for poor Peyton (wouldn't you much prefer JAke?) anyway...)

Then Lucas unlike lovely Jake who if he was in the same situation would have probably said..."i love you no matter what so whats another year" Lucas - who is too used to getting his own way like a spoilt child - couldn't handle the blow to his PRIDE!

So...who's fault is the breakup -...oh, um, i dunno??? LUCAS FREAKING DUH GUYS!!!

"1treehillfan"- no offence BUT the fact that YOU are calling LAURRA obnoxious and clueless is just hilarious...=P

^^ thank youu-

STFU 1treehillfan - you talk some bullshit! seriously - you said it about s1 - even if you did its still a load of crap- i mentioned how what you said was wrong for s1 too!

defs