If Nathan and Haley were to divorce, who would you rather Nathan be with? Poll Results - One Tree Hill

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

One Tree Hill If Nathan and Haley were to divorce, who would you rather Nathan be with?

86 fans picked:

Taylor James

88%

Carrie

12%

ohmygosh34 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

17 comments

	ohmygosh34 picked Carrie: I know Naley will probably never divorce, but if it did happen I would want him with Carrie because she atleast loves him and Jamie even though she is a psycho. Also if Taylor got with Nathan, that would be a betrayal to Haley. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	ElliesOwner picked Taylor James: I really wouldn't want him with either of these girls, but if I had to choose it would be Taylor, because Carrie is NUTS!! I think Taylor would be good, and Jamie wouldn't need a new mother b/c Haley would still be his mom. posted over a year ago.

	notthatgirl picked Carrie: He'd be stupid to break up with Haley. I would want him to suffer with Carrie. posted over a year ago.

	Othlover1272 picked Taylor James: i hattttteeee that evill annny carrie!!!! erhhh!!!! she desreves psyco derrek or sumthing!!!! but i guess i have to choose taylor!! at least shes not that psyco!! posted over a year ago.

	brucas4ever picked Carrie: it would be really messed up if he got married to taylor.... i would also hate him with carrie.. i would really like to see nathan with brooke; but that will never happen! posted over a year ago.

	mcewen_girl picked Taylor James: I know that neither of them will ever happen but if one had to i would pick Taylor cause Carrie is a phsyco bitch posted over a year ago.

	ShinyLicious20 picked Taylor James: i agree with mcewen_girl cuz carrie look FREAK psycho in shower w nathan somehow i dont like her. i like taylor, she is so pretty than carrie! posted over a year ago.

	abs07 said: yech, neither... posted over a year ago.

	livelovelaugh picked Taylor James: non really as it would be sick with both posted over a year ago.

	JolijnAdri picked Taylor James: i really wouldnt want either!! but atleast taylor is a little bit nice and she didnt try to kidnap their son! posted over a year ago.

	JolijnAdri picked Taylor James: AND she is not the reason they would get a divorce in the first place!! posted over a year ago.

	Leyton4ever picked Taylor James: how about neither....to move from a girl to her sister...eww and carrie is just crazy...but naley is totally endgame anyway posted over a year ago.

	sportygurl09 picked Taylor James: i don't want the bitch who broke up the marriage to be w/ Nathan... -.- posted over a year ago.

	Chlarkfan picked Carrie: BROOKE! posted over a year ago.

	Shelby13 picked Carrie: As much as I hate Carrie, that would be completely rude and tacky to get with Haley's sister! posted over a year ago.

	elinochka picked Carrie: well hate both posted over a year ago.

	Lisiii picked Taylor James: Actually I think they had a pretty great chemistry : D posted over a year ago.

Add Your Comment

One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill If Nathan and Haley were to divorce, who would you rather Nathan be with?

17 comments

Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment

One Tree Hill more polls