i don't understand why he couldn't just wait for her!! she said she wants to someday..but she wants to make her mark on the world first..i don't understand!!!!!!

THEY SHOULD BE TOGETHER!!

LEYTON FOREVER

now this one is hard for me because I do think that luke making it marriage or nothing was dumb on his part...however with that being said I also think Peyton should have said yes....so hmmmm

though to be completely honest the state of their relationship is the fault of both of them, not one or the other.

and after that he had to sink that low and ask lindsey to marry him ahhhh hes such an idiot

but peyton could have said yes.....that doesnt mean get married that day be engaged for a year or so then when you think that it is time to get married...get married...

i agree with miss73 .. they have been far away from each other and all he needed to know that she still wants him.. not someday but today! (they dont have to get married right away but just to know that what they have is for sure!!! )

its both of there faults but im leaning mostly towards lucas just for being a jerk and proposing to lindsey! i think lucas should of waited for peyton after he proposed instead he just left! she didnt want to break up! but peyton could of thought it threw more instead of just saying no straight off! to me she said no too quickly to have actually thought about what she was sayin- if she would of thought it threw she wouldnt be regretting it now! but if she wasnt ready she wasnt ready!lucas made matters worse by goin proposing to manface! :' he really annoyed me at that!

no i completely understand why she said not now, they both needed to follow their dreams and he should have waited for her if he loves her that much

just because you love someone doesnt mean you should get married! she wasnt ready for it she was only 19! im sorry but id hate to be married at 19 even if he did love me and i loved him! if he loves me that much hed wait! thats what luke should have done - WAITED!- when your 19 you should be goin out and having fun thats what id be doing not starting a family thats for in your 20s haha :P

SHE SAID NOT NOW... she didn't say no... she said someday... i thought it was kinda childish to end it because of that...

If Luke was ready to propose and commit to Peyton forever - then leaving her when she said no, just proves he should NEVER have proposed in the first place as he wasn't properly commited.

peyton had every right not to say yes if she wasnt ready i admired her so much for saying know as it showed that she wasnt goin to get stuck in the moment if she had sed yes then later on sed she wasnt ready luke would feel like shit

so dumb. like wtf