Glad to see i'm not the only one who thinks she irritating...it's really hard to like her lately.

me too! i was wondering if I was the only one...I understand she's lukes best friend, but leyton's break up was not peyton's fault, sure she broke luke's heart but he brought it on himself. Haley should be trying to help lucas with everything, but she's too busy,judging and yelling and acting like she's better than them, the whole she doesn't even see what's going on in her own home, and on top of that she isn't being a good mother or wife right now...I always liked haley too.

I think Haley is being a great friend.
She's being a very good wife and mum, even though she's not always home. What do you expect? Someone has to make a living for them and she's doing something she loves. A kid and a husband doesn't change the fact that she has to have a life of her own.

Anyways, Lucas isn't looking out for anyone. Not himself, Peyton or Lindsey. Someone has to. He is hurting the three of them all at once, and I think it's nice somone tries to control that. Lindsey is her friend just as well as Peyton is and she doesn't want her friend to get broken hearted. Sure, Peyton and Lucas belong together but that doesn't mean they can just ignore Lindsey's feelings.

i was never a big Haley fan but now she is just annoying! she doesnt even know all the facts but she is yelling at Peyton! she only knows Lucas´s side if she was a true friend she would listen to Peyton`s side too and then to decide!
i did like in 5x08 when she talked with Lucas, she asked him a good question!

Even though she`s Lucas` best friend, it`s not her place to meddle in his business. I know she only wants the best for him but she can`t try to make everyone`s life perfect when her marriage might be in jeopardy.

"Marriage is a big deal..." she can talk, she got married in high school. Plus she's acting all holier than thou, which is really annoying, especially because she kissed Chris.

othgirl_peyton, I think it's better that haley doesn't know "all" the details. I think she knows enough. she's able to approach the situation more objectively.

So to answer the poll question...meant to be or not, leyton made a big mistake sneaking around; again, lol. I don't think Haley yelled at peyton though. but she sure did tell her off and bring peyton down to earth a little...That was probably part of the reason why she let luke go as gracefully as she did. Yeah luke was an idiot for leaving peyton cause she said "someday" instead of yes to his proposal, but nothing justified peyton kissing luke. and luke certainly wasn't justified for macking with her. I love leyton but they deserved to be told off for what they did. and I'm glad haley was the one who did it. I only wish she woulda called luke on the cheating thing instead of simply saying he'd better be ready to commit for the rest of his life. I was hoping she'd talk some sense into him...Haley's luke's best friend. I think she was entitled to butt in a little. it wasn't like she was telling luke who to be with. she was calling leyton on their mistake and she wanted to make sure luke knew just what he was doing.

ritergrl: Haley knows marrige is a big deal, her marrige hasn't always been perfect and they almost got divorced and everything.
But she has a right to tell him off because he should know better. Just because she made a mistake (or in Naley's case, not a mistake) it doesn't mean she should just stay out.

i dont think she had the right to have a go at peyton for somethin both luc and peyton were doin and lettin luc off easy ... i can see why she is being like this because she is lindseys friend too an she is tryin to help luc by makin sure he doesnt make the same mistake as before. but she is one of peytons best friends, peyton as helped her out a lot in the past with nathan i dont think she shud judge her before she knows all of the facts... haley is goin off what luc has told her which is obv not the full story.it is not peytons fault they broke up... its lucs for not waiting. brooke can see that luc and peyton still love each other why cant she!!

i still love haley, i get what leyton fans mean but ive never been a huge leyton fan but i don't hate peyton or anything, i do probably prefer haley to peyton though

not at all!!
i like her more lately!

Laurra, it doesn't matter if they're in love - as long as he's with Lindsey, Leyton kisses are a big no-no!

Not irritating, but I really don't like her this season. It just always seems as if she'd like Lindsay more than Peyton

Tinna, I had so much I wanted to write on this topic, but you totally wrote exactly what I was thinking. I totally agree with you. What can I say but Great Minds Think Alike.

Haha, I guess so ;D I love when people agree with me ^_^

I think the whole Chris Keller thing is exactly why Haley has the right to tell off Lucas and Peyton. She knows what it can do to a relationship and she doesn't want Luke to make the same mistake she did.

Of course she was a Brucas- fan in the start of the show. I don't think anyone in the show was a Leytoner. Hello, Lucas cheated on Brooke with Peyton?