I adore the whole Naley's wedding(s).

This is hard. But I guess even I (a diehard LP fan), will admit that Naleys wedding was slightly more romantic. But ofcourse, it also depends on how you define romance.

Leyton's wedding was romantic too, just in a different, less obvious kind of way. Their wedding was much more personal, intimate, laid back, comfortable, and just very "LP". It was romantic because they really reflected on their history together, and how far they had come since they first met.. by bringing up the predictions list and everything. Their vowes (especially peytons) were much more real and unscripted, given the situation they were in with peytons pregnancy complications. Where as Naley's wedding was much bigger, more formal, traditional, sappy, the usual cheesy/cookie cutter vowes, a much more obvious in your face kind if romance... just very "Naley".

So I do think they were both romantic in their own ways, and in no way do I want to give off the impression that leytons wedding wasn't romantic... but I just think Naleys wedding definitely fits the more traditional meaning of romance

It was so romantic!

{And btw you used by Leyton wedding fanart for their icon in this pick!! :) }

Both are romantic.
But for me I chose Lucas & Peyton -i dont know if this was because i had been waiting for a leyton final wedding for like six seasons -they've wanted it for so long -and now they can have it :)
I loved the magic in the leyton wedding, it was personal and really bought the LP story to a magical ending -the way they were at the place (river) where they first met,the way they used the prediction box, the way they were all laughing. It was so beautful in the sense it wasnt traditional, everybody was involved & all the people that meant something to them were oresent. The reception was at tric -a big part of their lives, mia was singing -it was all just really perfect in an unperfect kinda way.

i did still love the naley wedding though, i love al things naley<3

i can see why most people would probably choose NH's wedding, but to me LP's wedding has romance written all over it. i've always thought that personalizing moments made them more romantic. like AMYonetreehill said, the fact that everything about LP's wedding had significance and meaning to them (the location, the people invited, the references during the ceremony, the reception spot), i think that makes their wedding more romantic than naleys. naleys wedding was sweet obviously, but i thought it was just too traditional and common for me to consider it as more romantic than LP's. weddings like naleys happen every day, but leytons wedding was much more unique, personalized, and meaningful

and hahahaha at Lucas/Lindseys wedding. probably the all time most UNromantic wedding in history

deffinetley, everything about it was flawless and romantic. i think the LP wedding was kind of a joke. the writers are complete idiots, everything was rushed and forced. and i think they intentionally made it light-hearted cuz they knew half the fanbase hated the idea of LP getting married so they focused less on LP and the actual wedding and more on other things surrounding it, with is why it was a joke. lol and i thought the LL wedding was romantic, lol the runaway bride an all? but i think i just loved lindseys wedding dress was the prettiest.

^ Lol i totally agree. I mean, in the middle of the LP wedding Skills starts yelling for Jamie, seriously? XD
They turned the wedding into a big fat joke. The only part close to romantic were the vows, even tho i don't considere them romantic, but more emotional.

Naley's wedding was much much more romantic! Everything was just perfect and carefully planed. <3

I also agree on the dress thing, Lindsey's dress was my favorite of the 3. lol

I loved Leyton's a whole lot more and I thought their wedding was more intimate,subtle, and magical. As for Naley's wedding...there was wedding was more "fairy-tale" type wedding so I would see that as more romantic but that still for me LEYTON's wedding was so much better and I loved the significance of their wedding with their love story and I thought it was more beautiful and I sure as hell was a lot happier during Leyton's wedding compared to Naley's.BTW Lindsey's wedding dress was the BEST I have seen in from any of the seasons! That dress was GORGEOUS and EXTRAVAGANT and Michaela/Lindsey looked beautiful in that dress! :)

Leyton's wedding was adorable but Naley's wedding was just PERFECT <3

Lucas and Manface's wedding wasn't romantic at all. She ran away crying! Ahahah!

Leyton's wedding was more laidback, relaxed, and fun. Naley's wedding was what you would expect in a wedding. But love Leyton!