Peyton's not my favourite character but I don't want her to leave OTH! And I sure as hell don't want both to leave.

If Peyton dies it's going to destroy Brooke. She's her best friend. And the other people from the core 5 too.

I don't like Peyton and I love Lucas .. so its pretty easy for me :P

Peyton/Hilarie is the reason why I watch One Tree Hill. She´s the best thing on the show.

peyton is to my reason,why i watch oth..
and she is one of my fav actreesses.or i would say my fav..
i would watch without chad ,show,but even only without lucas,that would be disaster,no leyton,no oth..sorry

That's a really tough question, but I'd say Chad because I was watching an episode in season three and Lucas wasn't in their. That episode was one of the best episodes of One tree hill to me. I'm not saying that Lucas is boring, I'm just saying that whether I wanted them to stay or not, they are leaving and it sucks.

I'll miss Chad and Hilaire a lot because they both brought so much life and excitment to the show. They really love their characters and it's not going to e easy to see One tree hill and not have Leyton. I'll still watch One tree hill only because I have watched it for awhile now and I can't help, but wonder what may happen in season seven.

You're right Taty, Nathan did a pretty good voiceover, JP was cuuute, Brachel were amazing, I totally forgot Lucas wasn't there
However the s2 eppy without Peyton was a drag.

as I said before I'm glad that they're both leaving instead of one or the other. Cause then leyton wouldn't have their happy ending. If Chad left then Peyton would be forced to move on and vice versa. So this question for me isn't a hypothetical hopeful alternative - it's the worst thing possible that would break my heart if it actually happened.

Peyton is my reason for watching oth, though I miss old Peyton, if Hilarie leaves the show...I'm not sure of being an oth fan anymore...plus Lucas is not the same boy I loved once.

I didn't want any of them to leave but if I had to choose I would say Lucas because he is my least fav character on the show!
Peyton is too great! Love her!

this is a tough question for me leyton and naley (brulian too but not as much as the other two) are the reasons i watch it but peyton is my favorite and lucas is 4th so.

This is not pickable :(

I want Peyton to stay!!

I agree with abs...enough said!

i love hilarie. shes an amazing actress.

Ok, this was the easiest pick EVER! I hate Lucas and Chad and I love Peyton and Hilarie. So this was pretty obvious :p

But it would still be better if either both stayed, or both leaved. 'Cause if only Lucas/Chad went away, Peyton would be left heartbroken, which we have seen enough of already. And if Peyton/Hilarie would leave, Lucas would en up heartbroker or he would start a new lovetriangle, which we have also seen enough of :p

I hate Peyton so I don't mind if she goes away!

I love Peyton but you guys all know my love for Lucas tops the rest of the characters :)

I like both characters (seperately) but I like Chad just a little bit more.

I don't want either to leave {but i dont want LP together lol} but the selfish BL part of me would rather Peyton be gone and open up more chances for BL.

I love both.. so this was hard..

I like both Chad and Hil but i love Peyton and don't want her to leave but Lucas can leave and like Taty said they had no Lucas in 3.20 and it was a pretty good episode. Plus their are not many who love Luke i know a few who do but other wise no.

cant choose!!love them both..and if one leaves then the other would be miserable so none

I mainly watch for Peyton. But I don`t want either of them to go. :*(

much rather have peyton but same as M^

What Kristine said

i am not answering this question cause they cant be separated....

if chad leave OTH.. it will be like what happened in the OC, when marissa left the show. chad tops the cast.

I like both of them, but I think it would be too emotional if it was Peyton who lost Lucas xD

jfiftythree
AGREED.

dont make me pick. too hard

i cant pick its 2 hard lol

Why not just cut off my arm! No, not picking.
Hilarie is an amazing talent, and wonderful caring person that has brought Peyton to life.

Chad is an extraordinary individual that has inspired so many people with Lucas, and inspired some fight over him too.

Both are passionate, both should stay. But as abs said, if I had to choose LP happy ending, or them both leaving then I say good luck, not good bye. I will miss both of them terribly. I would miss them more if Mark had more chances to screw with my brain. <3

btw I can feel the Peyton love, but....to each her/his own.

LEE NORRIS! :D

hahahahahaah LL!

I don't want either to leave, because i'm completely in love with Leyton, but i like hilarie/peyton more then chad/lucas. Peyton is awesome, i love her character, and Hilarie is an AMAZING actress.

OTH without Leyton would suck, but I take Peyton every time of the day. Better than losing both