i think she would i think she has that innocence and beauty that peyton had in season 1

i dont like her...she is ok i guess she is better then girl with huge boobs

hehe, i'm right there with you elina about the other girl

I don`t think she looks like Peyton at all.

she dont she is uglier

I agree with you guys but to me their is only one person who can do P.Sawyer justice and that is Hil but i think this girl can do an ok job.

I have no idea what Lucas saw in her. =/ Yea, i supose she's better that the girl with the huge boobs, but she's nothing like Peyton. And her face is a bit strange. =S

But i guess we have to wait to see, maybe she will become better.

Peyton is so unique i doubt she could bring a good Peyton!

I think she'll make a great Peyton actually ;)

i think she looks like a tupicall virgin high scool girl,too sweet plus her face looks like a horse face no offence

i really loved that girl,that girl want sex with lucas or director,phahaha
ok that was not good,but i don"t know why i"m not so much amazed with this girl

she's okay. but they could've done better.

Peyton is unique.....but that girl is so much better than the girl that said she would "totally" sleep with him to get the part! The girl that got chosen looks nothing like Peyton but regarding her acting.....I don't know.....she didn't talk

shes really pretty and yea i agree with livelovelaugh, she has tht s1 peyton innocence. and i guess shell do a good job but yea, she hasnt really acted or said anything at all for tht matter lol.

For me, nobody can ever live up to Peyton because she is my favorite character and Hilarie is my favorite actress and nothing would be satisfying for me, honestly.

I really don't know how Lucas came up with her of all girls, but I guess I have to deal with it.

was it just me or did all the "actors" seem really bad!