i excluded the first time as i didnt think it was fair we all know they didnt love each other then

i think he treated them both really wel but i went with brooke as hes never been bad to her the way he was with peyton like when he said he hated her and kissed her and proposed to lindsey in the same nite when he comes to peyton it was pretty sucky i dont count season 3 as cheating it was a friendly kiss it was a goodbye peck god ive pecked friends before lol but i went with brooke coz he always made her feel special but then agen when he was with peyton in season 4 she was in abad place with derek etc so that could be a reason why i think so

I was about to say a inamture thing but I delete it.
Sometimes is better to shut up lol
I think he treated Peyton better, even when he was with Brooke he treated peyton better than her.

do ya think? i thought he treated brooke really well

totally peyton

he did SUCH cute things for herrrr, it was very adorable and romantic :]

He definitley treated Brooke better!
He treated Peyton like crap...especially in s5!
I dont get how Peyton can forget all of that and say yes to him.

Overall i think that he should treat both of them better!!!

I reckon he treated Peyton way better then Brooke

I still think brooke and lucas were better together sorry peyton i love you but thats 4 me i love you Sophia bush

Lucas has always treated Peyton much better then Brooke

definately.

Peyton of course

lucas is always treated peyton better then brooke,in all sesaons,but in 5 season he was a biggest jerkkkkkkkkkkk..

Livelovelaugh...k, you talking about when he went out with them? cause that's how the question seems. but you're including s5 which doesn't count (the "I hate you" bit & the club kiss off). So I'm confused. Anyhow, whether or not you're talking about when he went out with them, for me, the answer's clear:

Luke treated Peyton like a goddess when they were going out in s4. He didn't screw up once! Yes, Luke made 2 crappy moves with peyton in s5 when they were split up, but with brooke, he's made crappy moves left and right...I'll list off the ones he made when they were going out:

- s3e10: The very morning after Brucas reunited - and were still in bed together, Peyton calls, doesn't even tell him what she needs, and still Luke drops everything (i.e Brooke) and goes after her. Then knowing that Brooke needs help with her clothing line ("How's it going" - Luke; "Like crap! Are you on your way back???" - Brooke), Luke chooses to help Peyton instead. Yes, ppl can call it "keeping a promise to a friend", but it's deeper than that. It was at the expense of being there to help his girlfriend who desperately needed him.

- s3e13: Wrote her a love letter that ended with the very same words he wrote to Peyton in one of his love letters he never sent to her (before s1).

- Never told Brooke about the kiss in s3e16 till he thought she knew and blabbed it instead @ Naley's wedding (s3e22).

- 3.17 Pushed Brooke away (which is understandeable, but he didn't seem to have a problem talking to Peyton in the library that day - infact he was able to joke with her and be real with her: "If I told you I loved you would you hold it against me? Cause I do, Peyton; I'm sorry about your moms. I feel like I haven't been there for you as I should and I'm sorry.")

- s3e20: Didn't call Brooke ONCE while he was away with his mom.

- s3e22: Used his past grace about the "Chris Keller" fiasco as a bargaining chip when he was trying to get Brooke to forgive him about kissing Peyton again.

- Throughout s3, though they had great times, she felt like she was hanging on for dear life ("I am hanging on for dear life, but i need you to need me back!" - Brooke) they'd go days without a meaningful convo ("I missed you so much when that happened, but it never seemed like you missed me" - Brooke); and overall, he never let her all the way in ("Why won't ever just let me all the way in???" - Brooke): Summing up all the crap he pulled while they were going out, it broke her heart, which led to her dumping him cause she knew a relationship shouldn't be like that; and she just couldn't do it anymore.

- s4e1: Didn't call Brooke about the accident with the bridge; and decided to spend time with Peyton pretty much the whole day afterward (Talked about Peyton's newfound estranged brother at peyton's house; made a mix with Peyton @ his house).

This doesn't even include the crap he pulled when they weren't going out (s3/4):

- s3e9: Left Brooke in jail 10 minutes longer than the others so he wouldn't have to see her; Basically called brooke a skank with the CK thing.

- s4e,2,3,4: While he claimed he was "trying to get brooke back", he was hanging out with Peyton everyday - which he knew (knowing Brooke knew about the library kiss; knowing it reopened old wounds from s1) would hurt Brooke - but he still made that choice.


Luke's trangressions with Brooke clearly outnumber the ones he made when he was with/not with Peyton. Ppl may say that the magnitude of his mistakes with peyton in 507 & 517 outweigh the many he made with brooke, but think about this: his mistakes with brooke were an integral part in the demise of his relationship with her. It always hurts more when you're dating the guy who constantly hurts you. With Leyton, Luke screwed up in s5 twice, but he wasn't even with peyton, and she never gave up on him despite his mistakes (she probably keeps all the good he's done for her over the years - cause there are a LOT of memories she can think back on when it comes to that). Everything he's done for peyton (always saving her; countless kind gestures he's done in comparison to the ones he's done for brooke over the years) outweighs the measling two times he's screwed up with her - and again, they weren't even dating. that's not to take away from the fact that he screwed up big those two times (especially the first; but let's not forget that with 517, he was devastated, and not to mention drunk!)!

So again, for me, the answer's clear.
Need I say more? :P

LOL exactly what Abs said! Lucas has NEVER mistreated Peyton when he is WITH her (ie going out) but he has Brooke!

100% agree ^ with abs!

once more i agree with abs07 she said it all!!

i agree with abs07 she tell the hall truth

go abs :):) totally agree

Peyton of course Lucas was always her guardian Angel even when he was with Brooke