One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill Prettiest Girl Elimination

dermer4ever posted on Jun 14, 2008 at 03:01AM
The way this works is every girl that has been on the show starts off with 10 points and you have one vote in the positive column and one in the negative. You can post multiple times. We will go trough until we have a winner and then start over and do it over until there is a winners bracket.

Peyton 10
Brooke 11+
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 10
Anna 10
Nikki 10
Taylor 10
Jules 10
Lindsey 9-

One Tree Hill 859 replies

Click here to write a response...
Previous

Showing Replies 1-50 of 859

over a year ago emybabe said…
Peyton +1
Lindsey -1
over a year ago Leytonfan4ever said…
Gosh i really don't wanna minus anyone, considering all of them are equally pretty, but i guess i'll play=]!

Peyton +1
Lindsey -1
over a year ago Janni said…
Brooke +1
Nikki -1
over a year ago ritergrl said…
Peyton +1
Lindsey -1
over a year ago Leytonfan4ever said…
Peyton +1
Lindsey -1
over a year ago Laurra said…
peyton +1
lindsey -1 (duh manface alert)
over a year ago Nine00 said…
Brooke +1
Nikki -1
over a year ago ritergrl said…
Peyton +1
Lindsey -1
over a year ago livelovelaugh said…
brooke +
deb -
over a year ago Janni said…
Brooke +1
nikki -1
over a year ago Leytonfan4ever said…
Peyton +1
Lindsey -1
over a year ago dermer4ever said…
Here is the updated scores

Peyton 16
Brooke 15
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
Lindsey 2
over a year ago brucas4ever said…
-peyton
+brooke
over a year ago Leytonfan4ever said…
Peyton +1
Lindsey -1
over a year ago brucas4ever said…
-peyton
+brooke
over a year ago dermer4ever said…
Here is the updated scores

Peyton 15
Brooke 17
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
Lindsey 1
over a year ago Leytonfan4ever said…
Peyton+
Brooke-

Peyton 16
Brooke 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
Lindsey 1
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago brucas4ever said…
+brooke
-peyton
over a year ago Leytonfan4ever said…
Peyton+
Brooke-

Peyton 16
Brooke 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
Lindsey 1
over a year ago fanny1780 said…
Peyton+
Brooke-

Peyton 17
Brooke 15
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
Lindsey 1
over a year ago Leytonfan4ever said…
Peyton +
Brooke -

Peyton 18
Brooke 14
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
Lindsey 1
over a year ago Leytonfan4ever said…
Peyton +
Brooke -

Peyton 19
Brooke 13
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
Lindsey 1
over a year ago Janni said…
Peyton -
Brooke +

Peyton +
Brooke -

Peyton 18
Brooke 14
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
Lindsey 1
over a year ago gogokef said…
Peyton+
Lindsey-

Peyton 19
Brooke 14
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
Lindsey 0
over a year ago ritergrl said…
+Peyton
-Haley

Peyton 20
Brooke 14
Haley 9
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago Janni said…
Peyton -
Brooke +

Peyton 19
Brooke 15
Haley 9
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10

over a year ago Janni said…
Peyton -
Brooke +

Peyton 18
Brooke 16
Haley 9
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
over a year ago jtu said…
haley +
nikki -
over a year ago Leytonfan4ever said…
Peyton +
Brooke -

Peyton 21
Brooke 13
Haley 9
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
over a year ago Janni said…
how did Peyton get 2 ++
And Brooke down to 13 from 16?
I`ll fix it!

Peyton -
Brooke +

Peyton 18
Brooke 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 10
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 10

over a year ago fanny1780 said…
+ Peyton
- Deb

Peyton 19
Brooke 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 8
Anna 10
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 10
over a year ago othgirl_peyton said…
Peyton 20
Brooke 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 9
Deb 8
Anna 10
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 10

Karen-
Peyton+
over a year ago Janni said…
Peyton -
Brooke +

Peyton 19
Brooke 17
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 9
Deb 8
Anna 10
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 10

over a year ago fr34kygl said…
Brooke +1
Peyton -1
over a year ago fr34kygl said…
Brooke 18
Peyton 18
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 9
Deb 8
Anna 10
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 10
over a year ago CatarinaSantos said…
Brooke +1
Nikki -1

Brooke 19
Peyton 18
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 9
Deb 8
Anna 10
Nikki 6
Taylor 10
Jules 10
over a year ago fr34kygl said…
Oh and:

Brooke +1
Anna - 1

Brooke 19
Peyton 18
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 9
Anna 9
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 10
over a year ago superstar_kk said…
Brooke+
Anna-

Brooke 20
Peyton 18
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 9
Anna 8
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 10

over a year ago Janni said…
Brooke +
Peyton -

Brooke 21
Peyton 17
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 9
Anna 8
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 10
over a year ago dermer4ever said…
Brooke+
Peyton-

Brooke 22
Peyton 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 9
Anna 8
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 10
over a year ago othgirl_peyton said…
Brooke 22
Peyton 17
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 8
Anna 8
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 10

Peyton+
Karen-
over a year ago dermer4ever said…
Brooke+
Jules-

Brooke 23
Peyton 17
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 8
Anna 8
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 9
over a year ago Janni said…
Brooke +
Peyton -

Brooke 24
Peyton 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 8
Anna 8
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 9
over a year ago dermer4ever said…
Brooke+
Jules-

Brooke 25
Peyton 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 8
Anna 8
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 8
over a year ago laffertyrocks said…
Brooke +
Anna -

Peyton 20
Brooke 15
Haley 9
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 10
Deb 9
Anna 9
Nikki 8
Taylor 10
Jules 10
over a year ago CatarinaSantos said…
Brooke +
Karen -


Brooke 26
Peyton 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 7
Anna 8
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 8
over a year ago laffertyrocks said…
disregard that last one :\

Brooke +
Anna -

Brooke 26
Peyton 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 8
Anna 7
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 8
over a year ago dermer4ever said…
Brooke +
Jules -

Brooke 27
Peyton 16
Haley 10
Rachel 10
Bevin 10
Karen 8
Anna 7
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 7
over a year ago laffertyrocks said…
Missed Catarina Santos' post,

Bevin +
Rachel -

Brooke 28
Peyton 16
Haley 10
Rachel 9
Bevin 11
Karen 7
Anna 7
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 7

(Correct updated scores)
over a year ago Janni said…
Brooke +
Peyton -

Brooke 29
Peyton 15
Haley 10
Rachel 9
Bevin 11
Karen 7
Anna 7
Deb 8
Nikki 7
Taylor 10
Jules 7
last edited over a year ago
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!