One Tree Hill The 'What If?' Game

loves-oth posted on Jun 09, 2008 at 07:38PM
ok, so this is a bit random, but i keep sitting thinking about oth, and about all of the 'what ifs' that could have happened on the show.

so i thought we could maybe turn it into a game?
i know it sounds weird, but i think it will be good to find out how one tree hill would have turned out if the writers had changed one little thing about oth.

so basically, i'll write down a statement, and then the next person will say what would have changed in the show, then the next person will go on to say another thing. if that makes sense?
and then once we've done a few, someone can start a new statement. does that make sense? [i keep asking that]

EXAMPLE

1. peyton never got shot in the leg at the school
NEXT PERSON
2. there would never have been then leyton kiss in the library.
NEXT PERSON
3. brooke and lucas wouldn't have fought at the wedding.
NEXT PERSON
4. brucas may still have been together in season 4

and so on...

---

so it's kind of like epi 4x10 where keith shows lucas all the might have beens...

so i'll start.

1. Lucas never submitted Peyton's art.

One Tree Hill 36 replies

Click here to write a response...
over a year ago doyouknow said…
2. Lucas never told her her art mattered
over a year ago cara_82095 said…
3.peytons stops drawing
over a year ago fanny1780 said…
4. Peyton wouldn't have express her feelings
over a year ago cara_82095 said…
5. lucas and peyton would of never dated
over a year ago Laurra said…
6.he would of never wrote 2 books about his love for her
over a year ago fanny1780 said…
7. He would never have been a successful writer
over a year ago Laurra said…
8.he would of never got engaged to lindsey ...
over a year ago Nine00 said…
9. He would still be with Brooke (yeah..i'm biased....)
over a year ago Laurra said…
10. peyton would be with jake && jenny :
'if brooke didnt have lucas would you still be here?'
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago Nine00 said…
11. Peyton would have never came back to Tree Hill and be happy

over a year ago fanny1780 said…
12. Mia wouldn't have become a famous singer
over a year ago othfanhoustie said…
Peyton's label would have not been as successful :(
over a year ago Laurra said…
luke would still have writers block (he rented peytons studio out to her and thats when the whole 'that day its like you touched my soul, and the other day you saved me again by the words you wrote about me in your novel, so if your struggling to write a next one, you should know - your art matters lucas .... its what got me here'!) <<< godd i miss them so much :'[
over a year ago fanny1780 said…
Lucas wouldn't have written another book about his comet
over a year ago Nine00 said…
Lucas would not be a writer at all
over a year ago fanny1780 said…
He wouldn't have stayed in TH
over a year ago 332960073452 said…
nathan would be coach
over a year ago hottie23 said…
Nathan wouldn't have got into the bar fight.
over a year ago loves-oth said…
haley wouldn't have hired a nanny.
over a year ago emybabe said…
If Peyton never went to the internship in LA
over a year ago addiee said…
if nathan & haley never got married
over a year ago alessandra_28 said…
jamie wouldnt exist
over a year ago fanny1780 said…
nathan would still be a jerk
over a year ago alessandra_28 said…
Brathan would be together
over a year ago loves-oth said…
brucas would never have happen
over a year ago fanny1780 said…
Leyton would have been together from the start
over a year ago alessandra_28 said…
Jeyton wouldnt date ever
over a year ago hottie23 said…
Jake might still be in Tree Hill.
over a year ago othbabay said…
Peyton and jake would be a family with tree hill
over a year ago hottie23 said…
Brucas would be together.
over a year ago othbabay said…
brooke would of never dated chase
over a year ago loves-oth said…
brooke wouldn't have gone to prom with mouth
over a year ago mischafull said…
brooke would not have a date and the pscho would kill
over a year ago kristenchappell said…
brooke would be the gothic side of her and never have become succesful
over a year ago hottie23 said…
Brooke's mom would still be out of the picture.
over a year ago alessandra_28 said…
c/b wouldn't exist