THIS. DOES. NOT. BELONG. ON. A. FRIENDSHIP. CLUB!

Oh my. ;n;

I haven't read any of them but Cupcakes, and I fainted while reading Cupcakes. D: So, I have to pick this.

Well, I only read Cupcakes before being warned not to read the rest so... Yeah.

*eyes widen* There's more gorey fics other than Cupcakes and Sweet Apple Massacre? *faints*

I don't plan on reading any of these fanfictions but I've read part of Cupcakes.

@dexisawesome: this is a club for a show about friendship. COMPLETE DIFFERENCE!
@PhoenixRoyale: be afraid, be very afraid.
@Tawnyjay: if you havent read the others then why pick?
@triq267: same to you my friend.
@xDark_Angelx: oh yes, read them, if you dare
@StarWarsFan7: ...what is it with you people and making biased decisions!?

I read AND WATCHED Cupcakes, it didn`t really scare me. But I have no further intentions to read any more grimdark stories thank you and good night!!!

I have not and will not read any more. I've read Cupcakes. From what I've heard, the other ones are worse. I've heard a lot of bad about Sweet Apple Massacre.

I've read Cupcakes, cried, read Cheerilee's Garden, shrugged, read a little of Sweet Apple Massacre, NOPE.

i've only read cupcakes out of the four, so yeah...

I read Cupcakes, didn't flinch, found it a good read. Sweet Apple Massacre, didn't read it but heard a reading of it. Okay, now it get's wierder.

Cheerilee's Garden, okay, THIS is Bucked Up!

neverread the one with trixie or the garden thought big mc killed 3 of them had sex with them cupcakes was horrible...and gave me a nightmare

Guess I'll stick with the one that started it all--Cupcakes. They're all about equally gory, though, to be honest.
Trixie's Funhouse and Cheerilee's Garden are pretty danged bad, too...and the latter is somewhat similar to Cupcakes. Sweet Apple Massacre is something that should probably just never be read by anyone, ever.

All of these stories are like the Aristocrats joke--they deliberately try to be as horrifying, extreme, disgusting, repulsive, and appalling as they possibly can be. It's pretty tough to get worse than Cupcakes, and the rest seem undoubtedly inspired by it.

Anyway, the result of such a thing will probably be a) utterly horrifying, as it's meant to be; b) little to no effect, because you know what you're getting into and expect them to do their worst; or c) amusement--if you've got a twisted side to your sense of humor...or simply because, aside from pure horror and disbelief, there's almost no other response to have in the face of such outrageous, absurd ridiculousity!

@fishypup: Nice answer. :) I agree...

my reactions
Cupcakes: a little disgusted, but the psyco in me eventually took over and loved it.
Sweet Apple Massacre: MUCH more gory than Cupcakes, i dont care what else anyone else says, i almost threw up when i read it, then i had a good psycotic laugh afterwards.
Cheerilee's Garden: longest of all the stories, so i got really bored, but the deaths were in good detail and were mostly planned out, kinda like a Saw movie.
Trixie's Funhouse: stupid, annoying, had no compelling plot, the only reason i put it on this pick was because at least it had killing in it.

The last time I went to ILOVEMLPs's house she told me about it.It sounded pretty gory to me!

Cupcakes is far worst IMO.
I've only read Cupcakes and The Rainbow Factory. So, out of those two, it's Cupcakes, and I've actually, literally passed out while reading Cupcakes, half way through and I regret it, totally.

Wow, I thought I was the only one who passed out reading cupcakes, guess I was wrong. Its strange, i'm no stranger to violence but i couldn't finish cupcakes. I got a little more than halfway through, then I woke up on the floor with a gash on my leg, I believe I clipped it on the side of my chair when I fell. Point being it was to traumatizing for me to finish.

At first I thought Sweet Apple Masacre was bad. Until just today I read Cheerile's Garden. My face the whole story: O__O HOLY S**T!!

I find it rather hilarious that most of the people on here have not read the others, and simply assume "Cupcakes" to be the worst. Here are my (short) reviews for each:

~Cupcakes~
I am a HUGE fan of Pinkie Pie (and Rainbow Dash), so "Cupcakes" hit me harder than most. However, I was still able to clearly decipher the Pinkie Pie in "Cupcakes" from the real Pinkie Pie. The syntax in the fic is good and the style is fairly well done. The torture/murder is descriptive and (occasionally) sickening. However, the story itself is greatly rushed.

Overall- A well standing, fine fic.

~Sweet Apple Massacre~
I read it, and... no... just no. The grammar, spelling, and proper sentence structure are lacking substantially. The descriptions were the strongest point of this story... besides its livid and repulsive content... though that does not say much. Its story was slightly rushed, but horribly written.

Overall- A distasteful fiction that should not be read once... and NEVER read twice.

~Rainbow Factory~
This is the only fiction of which I had trouble finishing (for reasons other than disgust). It is well written, albeit its description is confusing at times. The lack of detail about the setting became apparent to me and it made the story difficult to follow. Grammar and syntax wise, this fan fiction is nearly flawless.

This fic is the least gory of the four, but is one of the most atmospheric. Tension and building Terror kept me spell bound at its end. In my opinion, I believe that the author could have created a stronger overall ending/climax. However, the final words of the tale gave me chills... and haunt me to this day...

Overall- A slower, more atmospheric story with a poignant elegance to it.

~Cheerilee's Garden~
I've saved what I hold to be the best for last. Cheerilee's Garden is not only the most elaborate and gruesome of the stories, but it is also (perhaps) the best formulated. A limited number of spelling or grammar errors are to be found within it. It's syntax is well structured. The story's development has the same sweat-inducing effect as a ticking time bomb.

Foreshadowing only adds to the tense and intense aura enveloping the fic. It's death scenes are /beyond/ horrific. I almost vomited during the first! For two days after reading it, I was mentally disturbed by its grisly refinement. IF you decide to start reading this fic, make sure that you are determined to finish it. If you question whether or not you will be able to handle the story- Don't read it.

Overall- Fantastic! It's the most horrible wonderful MLP Gorefic in existence (in my opinion). I doubt anything will be able to top the staunch hellishness of this tale.

Well pinkie pie wouldn't stop taking out body parts from Rainbow Dash in "Cupcakes"

Have you even read Sweet Apple Massacre, what Big Mac does to those little fillies is not pretty

Big Mac raped a dead pony

Tbh I was laughing while reading Cupcakes, it was so stupid. I skimmed over a bit of this one and I want to barf. Why do people even write this sick shit?