My Little Pony Friendship is Magic
answer this question
My Little Pony Friendship is Magic Question
What do you think of the theory going around that Discord may in fact be Star Swirl the Bearded?
| Reasons For This Theory |
# They both have white beards.
# Discord can travel in time. (Star Swirl is related to the time spells because the section of the Canterlot Archives holding the Time Spell is named after him).
# John de Lancie has officially confirmed he has voiced a character in season 3, but he never said it was Discord. If Star Swirl was Discord, their voice would be the same.
# This Picture: link (Notice that the book has three stars and a swirl on it).
# The Amniomorphic spells could actually be the Omniomorphic spell, which allows the user to turn into anything, including a Draconequus.
# When Discord hypnotises Twilight and her friends, the background is shown as a series of stars.
# Discord remembered Princess Celestia, Star Swirl was also alive in that time because Clover the Clever mentioned him in the Hearths Warming Eve play.
# Whenever Discord teleports, stars appear.
| Reasons Against This Theory |
# No mention of it from anypony in the history of the entire show.
# It would mean Star Swirl descended into madness at some point and is inherently evil, so why would Twilight dress up as somepony on Nightmare Night who is evil?
# Lauren Faust never intended Discord to be Star Swirl when she created him.
# Discord isn't the only Draconequus.
# They both have white beards.
# Discord can travel in time. (Star Swirl is related to the time spells because the section of the Canterlot Archives holding the Time Spell is named after him).
# John de Lancie has officially confirmed he has voiced a character in season 3, but he never said it was Discord. If Star Swirl was Discord, their voice would be the same.
# This Picture: link (Notice that the book has three stars and a swirl on it).
# The Amniomorphic spells could actually be the Omniomorphic spell, which allows the user to turn into anything, including a Draconequus.
# When Discord hypnotises Twilight and her friends, the background is shown as a series of stars.
# Discord remembered Princess Celestia, Star Swirl was also alive in that time because Clover the Clever mentioned him in the Hearths Warming Eve play.
# Whenever Discord teleports, stars appear.
| Reasons Against This Theory |
# No mention of it from anypony in the history of the entire show.
# It would mean Star Swirl descended into madness at some point and is inherently evil, so why would Twilight dress up as somepony on Nightmare Night who is evil?
# Lauren Faust never intended Discord to be Star Swirl when she created him.
# Discord isn't the only Draconequus.
|
next question » | ||
|