Who do you think is more talented?

All biases aside, Gaga is still more talented. She has a wide range of songs, whereas Katy seems to do the same "pop alternitive" crap over & over again. Gaga changes things up, has something new with each song. Katy's are all sort of, I don't know. All her songs almost have the same message. & honestly, she dosen't have that great a voice. It's screachy.

Now, I will admit she is talented in some ways. She's got a good voice range. But that's about it. I think a lot of people only like her because they think she's "pretty" or "a good role model" both of which I disagree with, but whatever. We're all entiteled to our opionions.

I think Gaga is much more unique. Katy is kind of trying to re-create Britney Spears, Christina Aguleira, & Beyonce all in one. She's kind of a cookie cutter "pop artist" you see that's not uncomon. Those usually last a few years, & then they're on to the next one. I think that's what's in store for Katy. She's "in" right now, but she'll die out soon enough.


Anyways, this is my opinion. We all have those.

Gaga is more talented, because she can write about 2(or even more) songs a DAY! It's not difficult for her to write the whole album fast! She's also really creative and always impresses everybody! More than that Gaga is extraordinary! To be honest she inspires me!
God makes no mistakes, Gaga is on the right track, she was BORN THIS WAY!

GAGA!!!!

I'm gonna be the most sincere non-biased I can.
I like Katy Perry. I do. But Gaga is this generation's Madonna, there's no arguing. I know comparisons aren't nice, but Gaga marks a new era just like the Queen did back in the '80s. She's provocative, a true entertainer, she was born to do this. To say she's talented would be the biggest understatement ever.
I'm not saying that Katy isn't talented or that she wasn't meant to do this because, like I said earlier, I like her, but the more I watch their performances, the more I'm convinced that Gaga's a better singer. Katy has a nice voice, she really does but sometimes she struggles to reach a note and hold it. I think she got better but still needs to make progress.
I personally think Katy doesn't dance that much, she's starting to incorporate some dance routines now but not as much as I'd like her to. Gaga sings live while dancing in those outfits she wears... Gaga's a better dancer. When I listen to Gaga play the piano and sing the world stops for me. I've watched every single concert on YT since Nov. 27 in Montreal to the last one (I'm still waiting for her to come to Buenos Aires!!) and my favorite part, one of my favorite parts is when she sits in front of her piano and starts singing and talking to her little monsters because that is the moment when I think that she's a genius and her voice can't be compared to anyone's.
I consider Gaga to be THE popstar of these past years, she knows what being a popstar means and she can do it. I can't say this based on personal experience (unfortunately) but Gaga's mindblowing live. I repeat I haven't seen her live but from what I've seen of her in YT or TV has me always on the edge on my seat. I cried when she performed with Elton John in the Grammys last year. No artist ever made me cry like I cried that day. EVER. She gets to me in ways that I can't even explain... and I don't know why Katy Perry doesn't have that effect on me but I like her either way, love her songs and all but I'm just not that in love with her talent as I am with Gaga's.

I love both singers and i am highly influenced by them both to write songs of my own. But, if i had to choose between who is a better talented artist...I would say: both are talented in their own special,unique way.

After all, Katy can sing, write songs and can play gutiar which is good. Gaga can sing and writes songs AND play piano while singing her songs.

Also, the two dress unique too! I love both of their clothes, they both look amazing and keep me guessing what they'll wear next.

I would give ANYTHING to see Gaga in concert *i am seeing katy perry this july* because i hear she's got a good show.

So, all i am saying is that, the both of them are amazing,beautiful and havbe their own talents. So, do not compair them. It would be hard to because they both rock.

Katy Perry ♥
just Katy Perry.

LADY GAGA! her voice is amazing and she can play many instuments and shes a good dancer! katy perry can also sing very good, but i just think lady gaga is more talented. :)

LADY GAGA. JUST GAGA!

I don't mean to be a hater but I don't understand Lady Gaga. Katy Perry seems to be more talented to me because I haven't seen Gaga live so don't judge me for this answer.

i think Katy Perry is a much better singer

Lady Gaga is more talented. She's incredible at singing, a piano prodigy, writes all her own songs and is very fluid at songwriting, she even wrote many songs for other singers before debuting, can dance and sing at the same time, and what makes her stand out is how creative and unique she is. She's probably the most creatively talented woman in the world. Now Katy is also a good singer, writes her songs, and very creative, so she is talented as well. It's just Gaga's kind of better than her at all those things, and she's just more unique and has a wider range of varieties in her music. I'm a fan of both so I'm being very unbiased.

I would say Lady Gaga. Katy Perry is an amazing singer,but she has a lot of break up songs that annoy me ( Part of me,Hot n cold...). I love Lady Gaga because she can dance really well plays a piano and she loves art and all of her music videos have a moral or meaning behind them

Gaga

Lady Gaga is more talented than Katy Perry because she is a better dancer, performs better live, and can play multiple instruments.

Katy Perry

Katy Perry shows more diversity, creativity and imagination; she also, in my opinion, displays more genuine enthusiasm. She is more entertaining to me, and the way she vocally handles an almost two year long two hour show makes it clear to me how strong and durable her performance is. Her 'tunes' are never easy, some of them I've done my best to perform to audiences and they are extremely hard compared to the average pop melody. I believe that Perry puts a lot more hard work into making her visions work, onstage, in the studio, etc. I appreciate Lady Gaga, but Katy Perry's abilities as an artist are a true inspiration to me, in a unique way, which has a lot to do with the exceptional person she is.