Is bella and idiot for dumping Jacob and going back with edward?

OBVIOUSLY!!! i would've taken the werewolf cuz he is always hott in both ways. lol

*sigh*

No, she is not.

I am not on Team Edward or Team Jacob, I'm on Team Rosalie. So I'm not chosing favorites here...

It was smart for Bella to chose Edward because she knew she and Edward were soulmates; they absolutely belonged together.

Neither could live without the other.'

And without her chosing Edward, there would be no beautiful Renesmee!!

So no, she was not an idiot.

She was intelligent to choose her fate correctly.

Again, I am on Team Rosalie. I do not favor Jacob or Edward, I like them both fairly.

HELL YES

Jacob is without doubt the hottest guy i have ever seen! I think that Edward brainwashed her to go out with her.LOL!!! not really. but i think that she shouldve picked Jacob!

I think either guy was good for her. Both brought something completely different to the table for her. Edward made her feel safe and that no one could hurt her. Jacob was fun and loved to have have a good time. Both completely different men but both same because they both care sooo much about her. She looks cute with either one too. The thing tho with Edward is that he is sooo protective that he sufficates her. So...if I had the power to put her with either one, I would have to say Jacob. He is younge, fun, and hot. And he doesnt sufficate her. He gives her her space.

Well, technically Bella was actually "with" Jacob.
She just spent heaps of time with him and they got really close. They may have liked each other, but they weren't "together".
And Jacob knew that she loved Edward. So she didn't actually dump him at all.

First of all, they were never together to begin with. Not in the way she and edward were. so she didnt exactly 'dump' him. She just chose Edward as her boyfriend/husband. BUT i hated just how she kinda let on jacob!

yea! she is sooooo stupid! she shouldve stayed with jacob. she basically played him.

yes! Jacob is too hot and nice!

No, Bella is not an idiot for dumping Jacob and going back with Edward. I am Team Edward so I don't think that Bella is an idiot.

of course she made a mistake Jacob is like the perfect guy for her in every way there is.
i like edward but jacob is better for her.

yes i think she is a idoit for leaving jacob why cant she just pick one edward or jacob.

Well, after of sacrifice me in be girlfriend with Edward because he says than he is a different vampire and then he leave me without nothing softness and then Jacob make me feel better ... mmm ... Bella ... Jacob is better .

YES... he is soo hot and edwads ugly. Jacob was perfect for her.

HM THIS IS HARD SHE IS A IDIOT FOR CHOOSING EDWARD IN THE FIRST PLACE SHE IS MORE THAN A IDIOT

Bella is a naive thinking that she should be able to have both Jacob and Edward. She blatantly used Jacob knowing that she would never want to be with Jacob. The reason that Edward has so much self-control, is so boring, is because he is 109 years old. People flock to the ones that they love, so if someone loves you and you don't love then back in the same way, you have to let them go, so that they can move on to someone more deserving. He told her he wasn't going to give up, she admitted being selfish and not wanting him too, so that she could keep him around. They have an open, intimate friendship which would more than likely be more fulfilling, how about that kiss. She doesn't kiss Edward that way. Jacob deserves better than Bella, his love for her is totally unselfish, as he will prove over and over and over. I am about to finish Breaking Dawn, so I won't divulge the ending. Team Edward people are down on Jacob, but really, how nice are you when your heart is broken and you can't escape the one that you love. Leah is much worse, but eventually you find out her story and understand her a little more, similar situation. More werewolf fights, yeah. Jacob is WONDERFUL.

Bella was an idiot before that too. xD

bella is crazy for leaving jacob i mean who would go for edward seriously.

OK, so I really don't like Edward that much, but Bella is better with him because OK, like how upset would we be if Bella went with Jacob, then none of us could daydream WE ended up with him? So like I say, I'm Team Edward so Bella can have Edward and so I end up with Jacob! LOL Go wolf pack!