How I Met Your Mother

How I Met Your Mother This Or That

mikee21 posted on Aug 14, 2009 at 01:32AM
Choose which you like better and dont forget to leave one for the NEXT person

I'll star

Drunk Ted or Sober Ted

How I Met Your Mother 760 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 101-150 of 760

over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Marshall's hat. Lily's British accent is soooooo painful.

Barney not wearing suits to get laid or Barney trying to get laid wearing overalls?
over a year ago Buffygirl1988 said…
Overalls :) for the brotp moments XD

Don or Karen?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
oohh.. I hate them both! Karen cause she wasn't interfering with BRotp.

Barney and Robin or Marshall and Lily?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago Buffygirl1988 said…
Barney and Robin but I do love Marshall and Lily. I just love brotp a lot more!

Ted's daughter or Ted's son?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
hm... Ted's daughter.

Alyson Hannigan or Jason Segel?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Both, Jason Segel a little more :)

Lily or Barney?
over a year ago Buffygirl1988 said…
Barney

Lily and Barney or Marshall and Ted?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
hm..... that's a tough one. I'm going with Lily and Barney.

Lily and Barney or Lily and Ted?
over a year ago Buffygirl1988 said…
Lily & Ted. But only just.

Suits or a pot of gold?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Given that I don't know how good I look in suits, I'll take a pot of gold and sneak off to buy a suit with some of it. ;)

Ted's little dance in Nothing Suits Me Like a Suit or Ted singing Cheap Trick in The Pineapple Incident?
over a year ago Buffygirl1988 said…
Cheap Trick. He is so cute in that scene XD

Nothing Suits Me Like a Suit or Sandcastles in the Sand?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Nothing Suits Me Like a Suit. There is no comparison.

Let's Go to the Mall or You Just Got Slapped?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Has to be You Just Got Slapped! xD

Season 3 or 4?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
season 4

Rain Dance or Cheap Trick Karaoke?
over a year ago hstb said…
Cheap Trick Karaoke. I love drunk Ted!

Don or Tony?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
oh man that's a hard one... Don. he didn't make our boy Ted into a total asshole while glorifying himself in a major motion picture. lol.

Crazy Meg or Abby?
over a year ago hstb said…
Crazy Meg.

The Yellow Umbrella or The Pinneaple
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Pineapple!

Not a Father's Day or The Naked Man?
over a year ago hstb said…
Naked Man

Come On or The Leap?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Leap!

Twin Beds or Of Course?
over a year ago hstb said…
Mmm... I think Of Course

Ted's Mom or Barney's Mom?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Barney's Mom

Ted's Mom or Lily's Dad
over a year ago hstb said…
Ted's Mom

You Just Got Slapped or Barney's Christmas Carols?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
ohh... that's a tough one....... umm... You Just Got Slapped.

Carl or Wendy the Waitress?
over a year ago Buffygirl1988 said…
Carl

Something borrowed or Something Blue?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Something Borrowed :)

The Stinsons or Not A Father's Day?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Stinsons-- for the nice BRotp moment at the end! <3

Lily and Robin or Ted and Barney?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Woah that's a difficult one. Gonna have to go Ted and Barney though :)

Cobie Smulders or Robin Scherbatsky?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Robin Scherbatsky... I've never seen Cobie Smulders in anything else.

Alyson Hannigan or Lily Aldrin?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Lily Aldrin :)

Sarah Chalke or Britney Spears?
over a year ago hstb said…
Sarah Chalke

Trudy or Natalie?
over a year ago Buffygirl1988 said…
Trudy

Robin Mosby or Robin Stinson?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Robin Stinson!!!

Dirty Barney or Sweet Barney?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Hmmm that's difficult. Sweet Barney :)

Sandy Rivers or Crazy Meg?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Crazy Meg. Sandy Rivers is a douche.

Crazy Meg or the girl who wouldn't leave Barney's apartment in World's Greatest Couple?
over a year ago hstb said…
Umm... That's a difficult one... Crazy Meg

Voices or You Give Love A Bad Name?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
VOICES!

Not Moby or Regis Philbin?
over a year ago hstb said…
Not Moby.

Blue French Horn or Yellow Umbrella?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
SMURF PENIS!

Barney's daddy issues or Robin's daddy issues?
over a year ago hstb said…
Robin's daddy issues

Game Night or The Pineapple Incident?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Pineapple Incident! As much as I ADORE Game Night, the Pineapple Incident makes me laugh more than anything ever.

Spoiler Alert or Intervention?
over a year ago hstb said…
Gosh that's difficult... Spoiler Alert, but Intervetion is a great episode!!

"Where Were We?" or "Definitions"?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Definitions for sure!!

Barney's "FINISH HIM!" or Barney's Pac-Man noise?
over a year ago hstb said…
Pac-Man noise

12 Hours To Live Girl or Fake Proposal Girl?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
12 hours to live.

Let's Go To The Mall or Sandcastles in the Sand?
over a year ago hstb said…
Mmm.. Let's Go To The Mall, I think...

Marshall or Robin?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Marshall!

Barney's Angry "storming out" bar exits or Barney's frantic "dashing off to locate Robin Sparkles memorabilia" bar exits?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Barney's Angry "storming out" bar exits!

Lily's Dad or Robin's Sister?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Robin's sister.

Barney's perfect pictures or his one bad picture from Say Cheese?
over a year ago hstb said…
Barney's perfect pictures!...Hey there, sexy!

Zip, Zip, Zip or Murtaugh?
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!