Harry Potter Vs. Twilight

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Book elimination (for both Twilight and HP fans)

PotterForever posted on Oct 06, 2010 at 06:19PM
Simmilar to the character elimination forum, this one works in the same way. All HP and Twilight books are listed. Each starts out with 20 points. Remove a point from your least favorite, and add it to your favorite. The last one standing is the winner.

Sorceror's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisoner of Azkaban - 20
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 20
Deathly Hallows - 20
Twilight - 20
New Moon - 20
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 20

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight 90 replies

Click here to write a response...
Next

Showing Replies 51-90 of 90

over a year ago elliebee390 said…
+CoS
-NM

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisoner of Azkaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 39
Twilight - 13
New Moon - 11
Eclipse - 25
over a year ago CheekyCheese said…
+ DH

- NM (Even though I haven't read any Twilight!)
over a year ago IzzyOzera said…
Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisoner of Azkaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 41
Twilight - 13
New Moon - 9
Eclipse - 25

+DH
-NM
over a year ago youknowit101 said…
-CoS
+Eclipse

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisoner of Azkaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 41
Twilight - 13
New Moon - 9
Eclipse - 25
over a year ago smallypuppy22 said…
+ PoA
- new moon

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisoner of Azkaban - 25
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 41
Twilight - 13
New Moon - 8
Eclipse - 25
over a year ago jodarchy said…
+deathly hallows
- new moon
Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisoner of Azkaban - 25
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 42
Twilight - 13
New Moon - 7
Eclipse - 25
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago Renarimae said…
+DH
-New Moon

Sorceror's Stone-21
Chamber of Secrets-17
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Goblet of Fire-21
Order of the Phoenix-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-43
Twilight-13
New Moon-6
Eclipse-25
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago KateKicksAss said…
+DH
-Eclipse

Sorcerer's Stone-21
Chamber of Secrets-17
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-44
Twilight-13
New Moon-6
Eclipse-24
over a year ago KatiiCullen94 said…
NM+
SS-

Sorcerer's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-17
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-44
Twilight-13
New Moon-7
Eclipse-24
over a year ago LoopyLuna96 said…
+Chamber of Secrets
-New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-18
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-44
Twilight-13
New Moon-6
Eclipse-24
over a year ago Italktosnakes said…
big smile
+Chamber of Secrets
-New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-19
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-44
Twilight-13
New Moon-6
Eclipse-24
over a year ago alexthedog said…
+ Deathly Hallows
- New Moon(haha)
DH:45
NM:5
over a year ago lakota_spirit said…
+ Deathly Hallows
- Eclipse

Sorcerer's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-19
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-46
Twilight-13
New Moon-5
Eclipse-23
over a year ago Darkshine said…
+DH
-Twilight

Sorcerer's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-19
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-47
Twilight-12
New Moon-5
Eclipse-23
over a year ago mina_sit said…
+ Deathly Hallows
- New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-19
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-48
Twilight-12
New Moon-4
Eclipse-23
over a year ago duncylovescourt said…
+ Deathly Hallows
- New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-19
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-49
Twilight-12
New Moon-3
Eclipse-23
over a year ago la-la-la-45 said…
+Deathly Hallows
-New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-19
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-50
Twilight-12
New Moon-2
Eclipse-23
over a year ago Dracofan said…
+CoS
-NM

Sorcerer's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-20
Prisoner of Azkaban-25
Half-Blood Prince-24
Deathly Hallows-50
Twilight-12
New Moon-1
Eclipse-23
over a year ago PromptDreamer said…
+Deathly Hallows
-New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisoner of Azkaban - 25
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 51
Twilight - 12
New Moon - 0
Eclipse - 23
over a year ago emilykuru said…
+DH

-Eclipse

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisoner of Azkaban - 25
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 52
Twilight - 12
New Moon - 0
Eclipse - 22
over a year ago mr-cullen said…
-prisoner of azkaban
+eclipse


Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisoner of Azkaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 52
Twilight - 12
New Moon - 0
Eclipse - 23
over a year ago mandali said…
smile
-Eclipse
+Deathly Hallows

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisoner of Azkaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 53
Twilight - 12
New Moon - 0
Eclipse - 22
over a year ago mr-cullen said…
lol
+eclipse
-POA

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisoner of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 53
Twilight - 12
New Moon - 0
Eclipse - 23
over a year ago rosedawson1 said…
+ GoF
- Eclipse

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisoner of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 22
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 53
Twilight - 12
Eclipse - 22
over a year ago lukita said…
+HBP
-twilight
over a year ago loolymadness said…
angelic
+GoF
-Eclipse

Philosopher/Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisoner of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 23
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 25
Deathly Hallows - 53
Twilight - 12
Eclipse - 20
over a year ago slytheringirl7 said…
+ POA
- Twilight

Philosopher/Sorcerer's Stone- 20
Chamber of Secrets- 20
Prisoner of Azkaban- 24
Goblet of Fire- 23
Order of the Phoenix- 25
Half-Blood Prince- 25
Deathly Hallows- 53
Twilight- 11
Eclipse- 20
over a year ago TriaRose said…
+ Prisoner of Azkaban
- Twilight

SS- 20
COS - 20
POA - 25
GOF - 23
OOTP - 25
HBP - 25
DH - 53
Twilight - 10
Eclipse - 20
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago missdada15 said…
+Half-Blood Prince
-Eclipse


Philosopher/Sorcerer's Stone- 20
Chamber of Secrets- 20
Prisoner of Azkaban- 25
Goblet of Fire- 23
Order of the Phoenix- 25
Half-Blood Prince- 26
Deathly Hallows- 53
Twilight- 10
Eclipse- 19
over a year ago slytheringirl7 said…
+ PoA
- Twilight

P/SS-20
CoS-20
PoA- 26
GoB- 23
OotP- 25
HBP- 26
DH- 53
T- 9
E- 19
over a year ago alexisn10 said…
+Deathly Hallows
-Twilight

P/SS-20
CoS-20
PoA-26
GoB-23
OoTP-25
HBP-26
DH-54
Twilight-8
Eclipse-19


Everyone hates New Moon :( it was one of the best ones :/
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago RonGetYourWand said…
+GoF
-Eclipse

P/SS-20
CoS-20
PoA-26
GoF- 24
OoTP-25
HBP-26
DH-54
Twilight-8
Eclipse-18
over a year ago slytheringirl7 said…
+POA
-Twilight

P/SS- 20
CoS- 20
PoA- 27
GoF- 24
OotP- 25
HBP- 26
DH- 54
Twilight- 7
Eclipse- 18
over a year ago youknowit101 said…
This is taking you guys forever. You still have quite a while to go before you get rid of all the Twilight books.

I doubt it's even any fun when you're the only ones playing
over a year ago PotterForever said…
^ What do you mean? It looks like quite a few people are playing....
over a year ago PotterForever said…
Oh nvm Im assuming you're refering to the fact that its mostly hp fans? It would be nice to get some twi fans on here too, so it wouldnt seem one sided...
over a year ago cassie-1-2-3 said…
I quit because somebody yelled at ne for playing. I'd start again, but it's too far along.
over a year ago Renarimae said…
+ Deathly Hallows
- Twilight

Sorceror's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-20
Prisoner of Azkaban-27
Goblet of Fire-24
Order of the Phoenix-25
Half-Blood Prince-26
Deathly Hallows-55
Twilight-6
Eclipse-18
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago ThePrincesTale said…
Haha revive it xD

+ HBP
- Twilight

Sorceror's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-20
Prisoner of Azkaban-27
Goblet of Fire-24
Order of the Phoenix-25
Half-Blood Prince-27
Deathly Hallows-55
Twilight-5
Eclipse-18
over a year ago Renarimae said…
+ Deathly Hallows
- Twilight

Sorceror's Stone-20
Chamber of Secrets-20
Prisoner of Azkaban-27
Goblet of Fire-24
Order of the Phoenix-25
Half-Blood Prince-27
Deathly Hallows-56
Twilight-4
Eclipse-18
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!